EddieWalker said:
I've heard over and over again how women make better combat pilots on all the radio shows and in the news. A few years ago, a Professor did a study on this and found out that those claims were false. She learned that those being asked about the skills of women pilots were intentionally embelishing their skills due to orders from their superiors. Who ordered it and why was what the debate was about.Eddie
Hey Eddie.
Better combat pilots...hmmm, that's an extremely broad statement. Also, one professor's study vs. the United States Military's findings through both science and hands-on trial and error, just doesn't debunk the notion. Let's narrow it down a bit...
The
only claim that the Air Force and Naval Aeronautical Institutes found to be true about the very broad phrase of "women being better combat pilots than men" is purely physiological.
Combat pilots don't need a lot of physical strength, as let's say a combat rescue swimmer would. Ground crews do all the work, pilots show up...kick the tires and light the fires per se.
Cockpits are extremely small and ergonomically clustered in fighters as everyone knows. "Generally", a woman's anatomy better fits this profile, "generally" shorter, smaller features, etc. Also in high "G" maneuvers, because a woman's body (and I say again, 'generally') is more compact, the loss of blood flow to the hard-drive is lessened and even more so with today's high-tech G suits. "Generally" it was found that a woman's tolerance to higher G induced stresses were greater than their taller, larger counterparts. Blood flow distance is shorter...
Does this mean that a short, thin, male fighterpilot has the same advantages...possibly.
Source of my information: Pensacola, FL., Naval Aeronautical Medical Institute (NAMI) lectures, 1989, while in training there.
Not totally disagreeing with your post Eddie, just re-focusing it a little. There are exceptions to every rule, but in 'general' because of the physiological factor
only, it's true. The rest of the factors vary accordingly and are a crap shoot at best to quantify.
Boy am I ever guilty of helping keep this thread off-topic...
Podunk