Hit a bear, what about the bumper?

   / Hit a bear, what about the bumper? #1  

jcmseven

Veteran Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2004
Messages
2,314
Location
western NC
Tractor
JD 2320; 4520
Last Friday after Thanksgiving, I was driving back from my in-laws to work a night shift for a colleague who had OOT family visiting. I was in my GMC 2500 PU truck on the interstate. About 20 miles from my destination (I had already covered about 200), I had an accident of sorts. A reasonably large black bear (estimated about 200 lbs.) crossed over the oncoming lanes of traffic, hurdled the concrete barrier between the lanes and landed about two feet in front of my truck which was going about 60 mph. Since it was dark, there was nothing I could do to avoid the collision with the animal. I was in the passing lane with a large number of vehicles behind me, so it was impossible to safely stop at that exact time. In my rearview, I saw the bear still airborne flying over the emergency lane. It did not appear that it hit any other cars in the other two lanes to the right of mine, but I have a hard time thinking it survived this impact. At the next exit, I surveyed the damage and the only thing I could see is that my front bumper took a large impact in the right frontal area and has a large dent in it. The fairing underneath also was damaged but the painted area and grill above are fine (not a scratch) and the truck drives just fine (no damage to the steering or front suspension). Aside from feeling bad for the bear, I also felt bad about my truck as I have tried to take tip-top care of it (I love it--not quite as much as my wife, but close) and it has had nary a scratch on it.

My question, after all that, is that our insurance adjuster came by today and has made a claim estimate to replace my bumper, needed moulding and brackets, and license bracket. It appears there will be no other parts needed unless something else turns up. He said that his company approved the use of "aftermarket replacement parts" for my bumper/brackets. Thankfully, never having had to have repairs before, I am not familiar with exactly what this means. I told our adjuster and repair person that I wanted to use factory OEM parts, but how does one tell?? According to the adjuster, the GM factory parts have a 90 day warranty, but some aftermarket replacement parts have a lifetime warranty and he implied many came from the same supplier that supplied to GM itself. Aside from inspecting the bumper/mounting parts when they come in, how can I be assured that the level of part being placed on the truck is "factory level??" The adjuster indicated to me that many replacement parts are better than the originals, but that did not sound correct to me--as in general I have found it tough to beat the factory spec. This stated, he did seem both honest and helpful so I did not have the impression that he was misleading me. I just want my truck repaired, but have seen some highly suspect replacement parts in the past and do not want to get burned. Realizing this is a small deal relative to a vehicle with a more-serious crash I still appreciate the insight and advice. In the end, I spent the $$ made working extra to pay for the deductible on the claim.

John M
 
   / Hit a bear, what about the bumper? #2  
Sorry about that happening......You should have paid a comp deductable and not collision..Generally that's the way it works with wildlife impact. I have hit deer in the past and it was comp..$100 vs $500 in my case.

What year/miles and condition is the truck in?

As far as the bumper...I would talk to your selected bodyshop first...The reputable guys will give you an honest answer on the subject. Some aftermarket suppliers actually do source better chrome quality than OEM..Some do not. I feel that your right that OEM would be the most desirable because that's what was already there...

Fortunately, I haven't had to replace any late model parts in years, so I don't have opinions.

If you know the shop and trust them, ask them prior to any repair.
 
   / Hit a bear, what about the bumper? #3  
Some after market stuff is better than others. I'd be sure you have a reputable shop and discuss it with them and see what they say.
 
   / Hit a bear, what about the bumper? #4  
+1 on comprehensive versus collision. As for aftermarket parts, without evidence other than opinions, you have no clue about which is 'better'. Odds are that the new one, no matter the source, will be equal to the one currently on there, being some years newer, no exposure to the elements, etc. The factory parts will undoubtedly be more expensive. Everybody always insisting on the most expensive repairs for what is really no good reason - only a vague feeling of somehow being cheated - contributes to high premiums. Don't you think GM uses the least expensive supplier they can find? You bet your sweet bippy they do. If you don't trust your insurance company, you shouldn't be doing business with them, anyhow.
 
   / Hit a bear, what about the bumper? #5  
If you use after market parts it will diminish the value of your vehicle IF you ever plan on selling it.

Will the new buyer know, probably with carfax.

After market is a code word for MADE IN CHINA.
 
   / Hit a bear, what about the bumper?
  • Thread Starter
#6  
Thanks to all for the opinions/insight. I did pay comp rather than collision; the way our insurance for auto is configured there is not much difference in out of pocket cost (there is a long explanation here that I will spare each of you). Nonetheless, it is not a lot of money for me; I am just a little sore to be paying it in the scenario discussed. My truck is a 2009 model with just over 70K and is in immaculate condition. I did speak with my selected body shop prior to this and the shop operator essentially stated what ultimately was told me by the adjuster, that many "aftermarket" parts are of as good or better quality and have a better warranty. This shop is not local to me, but has been independently recommended to me by several people and my dealer (who does not have an onsite body shop). It was also an approved shop by my company. Tom, I appreciate your opinion (and asked for it), but I am not "insisting" personally on a more expensive repair for "no good reason". In my case, I feel my vehicle is a top notch, well-maintained and high residual value vehicle (which it is). I do not want to unknowingly find a replacement bumper on my vehicle that is of lesser construction and corrosion quality than that which I currently have. I certainly cannot attest to whether GM puts cheap bumpers on its trucks or not, but the integrity and chrome job on the one I have now is immaculate and I have seen some not nearly so nice. It also took a big impact and did not crack or buckle into the frame. It is my feeling that both my adjuster and the shop owner seem like honest people and have been good to work with so far (in the two days I have known them). It is not that I do not "trust" them, mainly that I have no experience in their handling of a claim of this type (never had one) and wanted to beware of any potential pitfalls on replacements parts that I need monitor. My view (though I may be wrong) on this has been that I, as the consumer, would want the absolute best parts and installation that I can get for the least amount of money out of pocket. The insurance company (not specific to mine) would seemingly want to pay the least amount of money it can and approve the lowest quality parts it can and maintain a decent relationship and business margins. My concern is that those priorities coincide. Thanks for the opinions.

John M
 
   / Hit a bear, what about the bumper?
  • Thread Starter
#7  
Cat Driver,

You said exactly what I was thinking.

John
 
   / Hit a bear, what about the bumper?
  • Thread Starter
#8  
Another, more specific, question is how does one tell on examination about the manufacture quality of an item such as a bumper or replacement part. Is anyone aware of valid certifications of which I should be aware prior to inspecting the parts (which I have asked to do)??

John M
 
   / Hit a bear, what about the bumper? #9  
Wife recentlty hit a deer with her 2004 Tacoma, the adjuster wrote it up for a "remanufactured" bumper. I am not sure if this means re-chromed or polished. Quality looks as good or better than OEM.

Good luck with the repair, and how many people can say they hit a bear.
 
   / Hit a bear, what about the bumper? #10  
Doesn't answer your question specifically but I would scrap the original bumper style and install an aftermarket "offroad" style with grill guard. Looks better (IMO) and more practical. That's the first thing I always do with a new truck - and I am going to start doing that to my wife's vans. I have never hit a deer, she reliably gets one every two years!:laughing:

Truck bumpers are not supposed to be pretty! :thumbsup: The truck behind them can be though. Add a hitch receiver to the front also:cool:
IMG_1242 (Large).jpg
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2020 INTERNATIONAL LT625 TANDEM AXLE SLEEPER TRUCK (A51222)
2020 INTERNATIONAL...
New Power Line 400 Plastic 3pt. Spin Spreader (A50774)
New Power Line 400...
2004 Honda Pilot SUV (A50324)
2004 Honda Pilot...
John Deere 6410 Loader Tractor (A50514)
John Deere 6410...
1998 VOLVO A40 OFFROAD DUMP TRUCK (A51242)
1998 VOLVO A40...
2012 SULLIVAN PALATEK AIR COMPRESSOR (A51222)
2012 SULLIVAN...
 
Top