Thanks for the ideas but not sure that will do what I want & need it to remain perfectly flat. What I'm looking for is darkened, burnished look of steel thats been indoors for a long time. I dont want it to look like it was simply 'outdoors'. Gary have you done this intentionally and does it look "old"? Do you have to rub it out? Not looking for "neglected" but "indoors 100 yrs old".
Sometimes I see items at stores, obviously factory-made to look antique, that are pretty smooth, even& dark brown, not rust red. Its not a paint, it is a surface treatment. No light rust powder or flaking, and it looks like you can get it wet and it doesnt change (much). This hearth plate will have wet boots on it, drying out in use, and I dont want the boots tracking rust around. Theres got to be some acid or something that they use to make new stuff look antique. Hoping someone knows a way.