Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?!

/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?! #1  

N80

Super Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2005
Messages
6,993
Location
SC
Tractor
Kubota L4400 4wd w/LA 703 FEL
My wife got me the new CD, "Raising Sand" by Robert Plant and Alison Krauss, yes, you read it right; heavy metal legend Robert Plant (of Led Zeppelin fame) and Blue Grass superstar Alison Krauss!

I was a Led Zep fan in my youth. Never saw them play but have seen Robert Plant in concert twice. I also like 'roots music' such as blues, blue grass and some folk music. (I have grown to despise the latest pop, rock and pop country music that is all the rage now). That's why she thought I might like this CD. She was right.

I suspect many people on this site know and like Alison Krauss' music but may be less familiar with Plant. Just as information he, and Led Zep, are often considered among the founders of hard rock/heavy metal.....and they were. But anyone who knows anything about Plant and Zeppelin know that 1) much, if not most of they're music was not hard and 2) it was heavily based in southern blues music, to the extent that some of their early songs are direct rip-offs of the old original blues men like Willie Dixon. They also dabbled in Welsh folk music. Since the demise of Zeppelin, Plant has had a very successful solo career and has had excusrions into roots type music. All of this is to say that his partner ship with Krauss is not as bizarre as it seems.

The CD is heavily influenced by producer T Bone Burnett who also plays guitar in some of the songs. The album is flavored with a blue grass feel but is very dark, and in places haunting. The overwhelming themes are leaving, infidelity, death and sorrow.....which are prevalent themes in most blue grass, old country and blues music. This is not a party CD:

"Sorrow and solitude
These are the precious things
And the only words worth remembering."

From the song "Nothin'" written by the late Townes Van Zandt

In fact, it should include a warning label: Do not drink alone while listening to this CD!

Regardless, I think it is a fabulous collection of songs. There are a couple that I simply do not like at all, but all the rest are great. Most of the songs are older songs, by varied writers including Mel Tillis, Gene Clark (of the Byrds) and the Everly brothers. There is even one song co-written by Jimmy Page.

If you haven't heard of this CD, give it a listen. You can hear the entire album at the Raising Sand web site. If you have heard the CD, I'd love to hear what you think about it.

Are there any music lovers in tractor land?
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?!
  • Thread Starter
#2  
I forgot to mention, they are playing a music video from the song "Gone, gone, gone" on CMT. I just saw it about 5 minutes ago. It is just awful and looks like it was slapped together in about 10 minutes. I'm surprised that Plant, Krauss and Burnett (who is also in the video) permitted it.

Also, that song, which is being pushed as the primary single from the album, is by far the most upbeat and 'pop' sounding song on the album. If people buy this album based on that song alone, they will be disappointed as it is not characteristic of the rest of the album at all.

The Rolling Stone review of the album was good but at the end, dings the album for not achieving a 'back porch' blue grass sound. Rolling Stone missed the point. It was never intended as such and in fact, was probably meant as an album best enjoyed in the dark, with a bottle in hand.....the emotional dangers notwithstanding.
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?! #3  
Not sure this is what you had in mind but....

YouTube - Hayseed Dixie - Highway to ****

The bands name is Hayseed Dixie. I first heard them years ago while working on the tractor and listening to the radio which did a story on their first album, A Hillbilly Tribute to AC/DC. :eek::D:D:D

Its AC/DC's hits done to Bluegrass. :D It works. I bought the album.

Doing some Christmas shopping Amazon popped up some suggestions on how to spend my money and lo and behold they have done a few more "covers." :D

I googled and found the video on Youtube. :D

Later,
Dan
PS. Just found out that supposedly two of the guys in the band are the sons of the man who wrote the Dueling Banjo song from Deliverence.
 
Last edited:
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?! #6  
You may be showing your age by calling the Zep' "heavy metal" :) Don't feel bad, I was once chastised for saying Ozzy was heavy metal, apparently if they don't scream into the microphone so you can't understand what they're saying it's not real metal.
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?!
  • Thread Starter
#7  
Well, 'heavy metal' was a term in a Steppenwolf song regarding rock and roll music of that era. So technically we geezers are correct. But clearly the term heavy metal has taken on new meaning these days. Zep, Ozzy, etc are relatively tame in comparison. Still, the likes of Metallica, etc etc will never achieve the 'rock god' status of Zep and their kind. Those days are over.
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?! #8  
N80 said:
will never achieve the 'rock god' status of Zep and their kind. Those days are over.

Unless you are a 10 year old fan of Hanna Montanna!!! :D
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?! #9  
I never considered Led Zep heavy metal. There was very few crunches (palm muting) and power chords. I always thought that the screaming into the mic was thrash metal, a form of heavy metal, but not true heavy metal. Metallica are the rock Gods of heavy metal but not so much since they became everything they sang against. I always considered Black Sabbath the first true popular heavy metal band. Distortion knob maxxed out, power chords, and palm muting. I spent many years in hard rock bands, but that ended when I almost cut my fret hand off on a table saw. 20 years of playing guitar down the drain.
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?!
  • Thread Starter
#10  
MossRoad said:
Unless you are a 10 year old fan of Hanna Montanna!!! :D

I think Robert Plant's female fans saw him in a little different light.

But seriously, has anyone heard the Raising Sand cd? It debuted at number six which is the highest Plant or Krauss have ever debutted as soloists. (Of course Zep had albums debut at number 1).

I find both Krauss and Plant to be virtuousos at their respective crafts but the chemistry between them on this album is truly amazing. Surely T Bone Burnett gets a lot of the credit for that but this album is a real jewel. Good music done well.

And I would agree, that even in their heyday Zep was not a heavy metal band, even by the standards of that day. They were far harder to characterize than that and far less one dimensional the the typical speed metal band who can do one thing moderately well....and nothing else. But still, Zep could do heavy metal and Whole Lotta Love is one of the definitve metal songs of the day (the words were stolen from blues man Willie Dixon). And there is no way other than 'heavy metal' to describe the dark, hard and moody 30 minute live performance of Dazed and Confused. Metallica could only dream.
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?! #11  
N80 said:
My wife got me the new CD, "Raising Sand" by Robert Plant and Alison Krauss, yes, you read it right; heavy metal legend Robert Plant (of Led Zeppelin fame) and Blue Grass superstar Alison Krauss!

I bought this CD a few weeks ago. All I can say is AWESOME!

At first listen, I thought it had kind of a Chris Isaak feel to it.

This album is certianly not what anyone would expect, especially given the artists. But, if you look at some stuff that Plant has done, like the "Honey Drippers", Some of it is not too far off base for him. He has certianly found broad horizons in music since the Led Zep days.

Interesting, in the interviews, it seemed this was more of a coming out for Allison; though she has done tons of collaborations, none have stray as far from bluegrass as this.

The album does have a slower darker feel to it, and yes some times haunting. But, it is done so extremely well. The overall ensemble is excellent.

They are doing a winter/spring European tour; suppossed to do a summer US tour...

re: Led Zep. I kinda think of them more as a hard/heavy blues band than any kind of metal band.

With this album, it leaves me still wishing for another collaboration... I would really like to see Chriss Isaak and Linda Ronstadt callaborate. He is an excellent musician and showman; she is an amazing vocalist.

There is another older CD that really suprised me; Patty Loveless and "Mountian Soul". She amazed me with the power and range she has.
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?! #12  
check out AC-Dixie.. they take rock songs and spin they with a banjo.. etc.

I've heard bib band workups of lots of rock songs too.

soundguy
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?! #13  
N80 said:
My wife got me the new CD, "Raising Sand" by Robert Plant and Alison Krauss, yes, you read it right; heavy metal legend Robert Plant (of Led Zeppelin fame) and Blue Grass superstar Alison Krauss!

After more thought, here are a couple things you could look at...

Check out the Chieftains. They had Roger Daltry on a live album as guest on a couple songs. "Blue Eyes" with a full Irish/Celtic band is amazing!

Another cool album, although a little older now, is Jethro Tull; "A Classic Case". Full orchestra backing them up, it sounds awesome!

I am less enthused about country these days; too much is either cross over to pop, or too much rock. As much as I like outlaws like the '70's Wille/Waylon/Kris, I still like more traditional county. And, these days, the country stations around here are top/pop country; the same songs again and again...

try Pandora.com, and plug in Patsy Kline; you'll get a great mix :D Or, Stivie Ray Vaughn :D :D

try listening to Welcome to KVMR - Music of the World. Voice of the Community. Nevada City, California streaming audio on saturdays 10am-4pm PST. Also weds eve, 8pm PST. Awesome bluegrass show, traditional country, and one Weds a great celtic show.
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?!
  • Thread Starter
#14  
RobertN said:
I bought this CD a few weeks ago. All I can say is AWESOME!

At first listen, I thought it had kind of a Chris Isaak feel to it.

I like Chris Isaak a lot. I think "Wicked Game" is one of the best songs ever written.

Interesting, in the interviews, it seemed this was more of a coming out for Allison; though she has done tons of collaborations, none have stray as far from bluegrass as this.

While I do love this album, and would like to see Krauss do other collaborations, I would not want to see her turned into a pop artist. I would much rather see her continue to grow famous but within the bounds of good honest blue grass and roots type music.

The album does have a slower darker feel to it, and yes some times haunting. But, it is done so extremely well. The overall ensemble is excellent.

Yep, I think the other band members are superb. Both Plant and Krauss have always surrounded themselves with talented musicians. I found the steel guitar on this album to be particularly well done. So often it seems like steel guitar is a gratuitous add-on just to make a song sound 'country'. On this album it is honest, understated and the timing is perfect.

They are doing a winter/spring European tour; suppossed to do a summer US tour...

I haven't been to a concert (other than symphony) in probably 12 years. I would love to see this duo in a small venue and would pay good money to do so. Robert Plant is one of the most amazing live performers I've ever seen. I saw him about 15 years ago in Columbia, SC (which would have to seem like a provencial arm pit to him) and it seemed like he was having the time of his life during that show. He seemed to genuinely be having fun. Either he loves his work or he is a great actor.

With this album, it leaves me still wishing for another collaboration... I would really like to see Chriss Isaak and Linda Ronstadt callaborate. He is an excellent musician and showman; she is an amazing vocalist.

Love Isaak but have never paid much attention to Ronstadt. She was certainly a great vocalist in her day....does she still have it?

But I agree, I'd like to see more people doing this sort of thing. Either digging up good old stuff or writing new basic, soulful roots music and doing it with true artistic talent. Pop country has no appeal for me. Rock seems to be finally dead or at least in the noisy death throes. Maybe its time for a revival of the good old stuff done by consumate artists. I think there is a market for it.
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?! #15  
I guess I'm way out of touch, I know who Robert Plant is, but have no idea who Alison Krauss is. I'm only 47, do I qualify as an old geezer? :eek:

Steve
Nova Scotia
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?! #16  
Steve_Miller said:
I guess I'm way out of touch, I know who Robert Plant is, but have no idea who Alison Krauss is. I'm only 47, do I qualify as an old geezer? :eek:

Steve
Nova Scotia

Allison is an exceptional bluegrass fiddler, and wonderful singer. She started playing fiddle at a young age, and by teen's was winning fiddle and violin contests all over the US. She primarily is with her own band, Allison Krauss and Union Station.

She has done some country duets, and scores for a number of movies.
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?! #17  
N80 said:
Love Isaak but have never paid much attention to Ronstadt. She was certainly a great vocalist in her day....does she still have it?

Oh ya, she's still got it. And, better as time goes on. She was a good untrained vocalist. In the early 80's when she paired up with Nelson Riddle, she also got voice training. It never ceases to amaze me the range she has, from folk, country, pop, rock, spanish, jazz, Broadway.... Although there are other female vocalist who may be good in one genre of music, Linda can do many, exceptionally well.
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?! #18  
RobertN said:
Allison is an exceptional bluegrass fiddler, and wonderful singer. She started playing fiddle at a young age, and by teen's was winning fiddle and violin contests all over the US. She primarily is with her own band, Allison Krauss and Union Station.

She has done some country duets, and scores for a number of movies.

Allison Krauss is 36 so she is younger then you so you may be an old geezer (she is older then me though (29))

Alison Krauss - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?! #19  
Just listened to the youtube promo on the album. Will most likely have to get the album. Can't stand the most of the new "country music" myself, or pop or rap. I really like some of Josh Turner's stuff, I just wish he would stay away from the goofy songs. I generally like the old country stuff and traditional bluegrass, Ralph Stanley, Bill Monroe, Earl Scrugg(he's 84 tomorrow)ect.
I like colaborations like this that push the artists to have to work toward a different stlye music. Some really good stuff comes out of it.
If you want to hear something real different check out some songs by Gillian Welch.
And no I'm probably not as old as a lot of people would think I am from that post. Just turned 46.
 
/ Heavy Metal + Blue Grass?!?!
  • Thread Starter
#20  
Right. And she's not going to be a household name like Brittney Spears or Kenny Chesney. Its blue grass after all. Not pop. And blue grass is never going to be as marketable as pop. Which is fine. Krauss is an extremely talented vocalist and a superb fiddler, far more talented than any of the pop and pop country musicians that I'm aware of.

Her soundtrack appearances have given her career a boost. I've been aware of her for quite some time but first got interested from her songs on the "Oh Brother, Where Art Thou" soundtrack which was very popular and gave blue grass a real popularity kick.

I like her music and I like blue grass but don't own an album of either. That may change soon. I really like live blue grass and have had a lot of opportunities to enjoy it. Shindig on the Green, an event that occurs every Friday night during the summers in Asheville, NC is a truly excellent musical experience with tons of talented performers, most of them local. All blue grass.
 
 
Top