While I agree in personal restraint if thats what you want to manage your area it isn't yours or anyone elses right (well, except the state I guess) to tell someone else they shouldn't shoot a legal deer if they have the opportunity. Not everyone hunts for a mega trophy deer. Heck, a lot of hunters in a lot of areas would go their entire lives and never shoot or even see a deer the size that was taken in this thread. My friend who is in his 50's killed his very first buck this year on our land. He has hunted over 30 years and for various reasons just never managed to shoot a buck. It was a nice buck but nothing that would make the record books but it was the highlight of his hunting career. I personally have 3 decent bucks hanging on my wall that mean something to me. I don't shoot young bucks and let them walk and get older yet this year I shot a 4 point and it was the most memorable deer I have ever taken so far, the reason being, my 7 year old daughter had been with me and the smile on her face and her reaction and excitement brought more joy to me then anything else. Theres so much more to hunting then the size of a bucks antlers and as long at the hunter is happy and enjoying their time outdoors then no one should say anything to discourage them.