Cub Cadet Choices

/ Cub Cadet Choices #1  

RCT

Bronze Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2005
Messages
67
Location
Raleigh, NC
Tractor
Cub Cadet 2138
I am trying to decide on a new tractor. I have picked out three Cubs. Anybody have experience with a LT1050 or LT 2042 or RZT 42? I want something that has serviceable not replaceable parts (had a Murray with a bad hydro that had to be replaced to the tune of $900). Is the 2042 that much better? My yard is about 3/4 acreand I don't want to spend much more than $2,500 (I will have to save quite awhile to get that)>.
 
/ Cub Cadet Choices #2  
Of those three I would go with the LT1050. Its a great machines for the money. I would stay wawy from the RZT42...if you wanted a zero turn I would get the RZT50. I would only go for the 2000 series if you had steep inclines or needed to pull something. The 1050 is probably your best bet...try to purchase from a dealer and not Lowes.
 
/ Cub Cadet Choices
  • Thread Starter
#3  
I do have a little bit of a slope on one side of the yard. As far as pulling, I saved the frame with all 4 wheels still attached so I could build a trailer out of it later (only thing worth anything on the Murray). Also, I considered the SLT 1554. Just want to be able to get the yard done as quick as possible. I have quite a few trees/shrubs to maneuver around. Don't think I can wait to save up the $3,000 for the RZT 50 though. Finally what is the difference in a "serviceable tranny in the 1000s and the fully serviceable tranny in the 2000s. Are the hydros any good in the RZT 42? (The whole Murray incident).
 
/ Cub Cadet Choices #4  
The trailer I think you'd make from the old mower shouldn't be a burden on any machine. 3/4 acre and gentle landscape shouldn't throw too many red flags either, although the target price on lawn tractors is so aggressive these days that I'd go as heavy as possible anyway [don't think your needs really call for a GT though].

Now the quandry, you say as fast a possible. If you have obstacles, the ZTR is the choice for cutting time. The RZTs didn't impress me, but they were made for lawns like yours. I didn't recall much advantage of the 50; it has the twin cylinder, larger tires, 4pt antiscalp...maybe that is enough difference; Gamble would know better than I.

My statements on RZTs aren't exactly fair anyway; I was actually comparing the ZForce to a true commercial machine at the same time I looked over the RZTs. Rumor around the web is 800 hours on the EZT integrated pump/motor [sorry if I'm propogating rumor here]. The IZT, like the ZForce, sure seems beefer [and gives me more of a "warm-fuzzy", but I haven't seen anything that diffinitively states longer life. I guess if I were saving for a mower in that ballpark, I'd hobble something by unit I'd afford the ZForce44; however, if I'm imagining your lawn right, I don't know of a bad choice.

Last note: All other things being equal, since a Zturn cuts mowing time, you'll have maybe 2/3 the hours on the engine in 10 years [actually every time you mow for that matter] as you would a LT.
 
/ Cub Cadet Choices
  • Thread Starter
#5  
Well by my calculations...
It took about 1 1/2 hours with the Murray to cut the grass with a 42" deck. Assuming 2/3 the time that is 1 hour times 7 months cutting that is 30 hours per year. Or about 26 years at 800 hours life. Any way to maintain the hydros in the RZT 42 (change the oil, etc)? Sorry, I'm an accountant by trade.
 
/ Cub Cadet Choices #6  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( Well by my calculations...
It took about 1 1/2 hours with the Murray to cut the grass with a 42" deck. Assuming 2/3 the time that is 1 hour times 7 months cutting that is 30 hours per year. Or about 26 years at 800 hours life. Any way to maintain the hydros in the RZT 42 (change the oil, etc)? Sorry, I'm an accountant by trade. )</font>

Mmmmm...zactly! Someone should substantiate this all... but so far it's been fairly well substantiatedi that it is capable of lasting this long... it going to last as long as you probably expect it to.... fact is... no one knows... it could be more...
 
/ Cub Cadet Choices
  • Thread Starter
#7  
I don't really expect it to last that long but 10-15 years would be nice.
 
/ Cub Cadet Choices #8  
An accountant?! /forums/images/graemlins/wink.gif Just buy the M48 Tank [the M60 is beautiful, but your obstacles are probably too tight]..... /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif

Anyway, reasonable sized lot, no abuse, and reasonable expections: I think you would be very happy with a consumer or residential Z [i.e. the RZT]. Hopefully though, Gamble can give a bit more detail on his distinct advice to the 50 over 42.

The only thing I know about the maintenance; the IH [cub]dealer here said they never have trouble except some of the earlier ones [and that was I think the IZTs] would take on moisture if left in the rain; supposedly this would do some pretty quick damage if ran that way.
 
/ Cub Cadet Choices #9  
Almost forgot, if you use your trailer on any residential ZTR, long before you endanger the engine or trannys, stability may be spooky.....With the pictures of your lawn and your trailer my mind conjured up, it still shouldn't be an issue.
 
/ Cub Cadet Choices #10  
My reasons for liking the RZT50 over the RZT42 are just like Chad said. I don't like the single cylinder engines, especially the Briggs, don't like that it doesn't have anti-scalp wheels...I just don't feel "confident" selling it to customers. I have sold one in the past two years and the guy special ordered it, I don't stock them.

The transmissions in the RZT's are not servicable.

I think you can narrow your search to two units...the LT1050 and the RZT50. Obviously the RZT will give you a better cut as well as cut your time in almost half. The LT1050 is a great little machine for the $. I think the 2000 series is a little over-kill for you needs. The "fully servicalbe" trans (has its own filter) is nice, as is the drive shaft but for your land and your needs I really don't think you will need those "extras."

So...now you get to decide if you want to spend another $1000 and cut your mowing time in half!
 
/ Cub Cadet Choices
  • Thread Starter
#11  
Yes, I had kind of eliminated the 2042 after seeing the 26.5" turning radius. The 1050 has about the same turning radius as the Murray did with a bigger deck. So it seems like I might gain a little time with the 1050, but not much. The RZT seems like the way to go. As a dealer, do you know if the prices on Cub's web site are discounted at the dealers? I definitely want to get it from a dealer. Also, what about used machines should I look for.
 
/ Cub Cadet Choices #12  
The dealers posting here would likely have better answers, but it does seem there is not much dickering room on the residential machines [including the ZF]. It seems that the web-site, ads, and full dealer as well as "volume" dealer prices are fairly in sync. One IH dealer up here was pretty rigid, the other was ready to knock about 4% [essentially the tax] off of a 4K ZForce50.

That said, I know at least one member found about 10% off of a ZF44. Also, if you could inspect it at pick it up, there is a ZF44 selling on EBay...I think the retail was mislisted. After this thread, I'm even less keen on the RZT42, but if you still like it, there's an 04 I'm guessing a few hours away from you listed for 2K/SubmitOffer on Ebay too.

I think you are wise to focus your shopping at dealers; too many of the "volume" guys just aren't informed enough [or too over-zealous] to make reasonable recomendations (granted, I'm sure there are a few bad dealers, and a few good "lawn dept." salesmen). Don't think dealers make too much per unit, but I'm guessing they save enough paperwork that if it comes in for warranty work they'll be much happier to see your face if you bought from them. Not sure, but I'm also guessing there's probably "brownie points" or at least braggin' rights if they move enough units [wonder if they'd give you a prize for buying the last one of the truck load?! /forums/images/graemlins/wink.gif].
 
/ Cub Cadet Choices
  • Thread Starter
#13  
I got to use my neighbor's Cub 1018 Sunday. It did a good job and didn't get stuck at all where the Murray used to. It took about 1 1/2 hours. Half of that would be nice. I am pretty set on the RZT 50, but would like to test it on my yard. Will the dealers let you do that?? If for some reason the RZT 50 doesn't work, I am considering the SLT 1554 due to the 54" cut. Any feedback on the 1554??
 
/ Cub Cadet Choices #14  
I drove the SLT1554 and thought it was slow, especially compated to the RZT50. Have about 21 hours on my, or should I say my wife's RZT50 and haven't regretted our purchase. Got it for $2850 at local dealer with 12 months same as cash.
Good luck.
 

Marketplace Items

2023 NISSAN ALTIMA SEDAN (A59914)
2023 NISSAN ALTIMA...
Neckover GL24-2-7K Gooseneck Trailer  24ft Deck, Dual 7K Axles, 14K GVWR (A63689)
Neckover GL24-2-7K...
2015 MACK GRANITE (A65643)
2015 MACK GRANITE...
Trump 2028 Metal Sign (A65583)
Trump 2028 Metal...
Case IH 200 50' Field Cultivator (A66285)
Case IH 200 50'...
Mayrath 30' Auger (A66285)
Mayrath 30' Auger...
 
Top