BX23 or B2630?

   / BX23 or B2630? #1  

MBCF

New member
Joined
May 19, 2005
Messages
3
Location
Sullivan County NH
Tractor
BX23TLB
I’m stuck deciding between tractors, the BX 23 TLB with 60 in MMM and the B2630 LA403/BH75 with a 60in MMM.

We have just under six acres half of which I mow, the former owner was a golfer, the other half of the property is wooded. The wooded half has a 100-foot deep gully that occupies about and acre. Yeah, a nice little water fall when the creek runs. The creek runs out of a seep (A potential pond?) that is part on my property and part on a neighbors it becomes a creek about 150 feet in from the property line, this factors in to doing anything on the other side of the creek. There is also a half-acre of grass on a 35-degree slope that I mow with a JD LX 173 with a thirty-eight inch deck. It takes me about 4 and 1/2 hours to mow everything that gets mowed.

Mowing is a big part of the deal. The Minister of Finance, my wife, says no point in getting a tractor unless it makes life easier for you. So, the 60-inch (Fits between the raised beds of the veggie garden.) mower is a must. Other projects include replacing the 24 ft bridge over the creek. Cleaning out the gully, the former owner believed in the time honored New England tradition of pitching junk (A 500 gallon oil tank?) off the side of the nearest slope. Assorted landscaping duties as dictated by the Minister of Finance, my wife. I would like to start doing a better job of managing the wooded part of the land, perhaps expand the lawn in the nice areas and plant trees in the areas I don’t want to mow. We have wanted to put in a small orchard on the 35-degree slope. There is also a small (half-acre), pre subdivision, gravel pit on the property that could be made useful if I could get to it easily. This would require breaking through the 30 ft wide by 20 ft high rim of the pit.


Given the terrain taking the MMM off will be necessary for most non-mowing tasks. I’m leaning toward the B2630 but worry the MMM backhoe or loader will be more of a pain to get on and off than on a BX23?

Because of all the hills and such on the property an other concern is “stabilty” The B2630 is higher off the ground and looks like it will tip easier that the BX23? Will my wife not want to help with the mowing because the tractor is “too high up”?

What about renting implements? Is it easier to find, say a tiller that would work on the B2630? Will I be stuck buying BX 23 specific implements from Kubota?

Price? The B2630 is just over $6K more than the BX23 what else besides more power and larger volume buckets am I getting for my and the Finance Ministers buck?

This is probably the last tractor I will ever buy.

Thanks MBCF
 
   / BX23 or B2630? #2  
Tough to answer. You make a good case for either tractor.

See if your dealer will visit your location, look at the layout and make a recommendation. Ask detailed why questions about the recommendation both pro and con about both choices. Hopefully, he won't just try to sell you the more expensive unit.
 
   / BX23 or B2630? #3  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( What about renting implements? Is it easier to find, say a tiller that would work on the B2630? Will I be stuck buying BX 23 specific implements from Kubota? )</font>

I would assume "yes" to your first question. From what I've read, there are some 3PH cat 1 implements that just won't work well, or fit well, with the limitted cat 1 3PH of the BX23. I believe this is mainly due to the ground clearance. PH diggers and tillers I believe are the two common implements you may have trouble renting.

As for your 2nd question, you don't have to buy them from Kubota. There are plenty of manufacturers of SCUT implements, and not all SCUT implements need built differently than a CUT implement.
 
   / BX23 or B2630? #4  
I know I'd be happier with the taller tires and more ground clearance for the jobs you described.
 
   / BX23 or B2630? #5  
<font color="blue"> There is also a half-acre of grass on a 35-degree slope that I mow with a JD LX 173 with a thirty-eight inch deck. </font>

I don't think you want to be taking either the BX or a B2630 on a 35 DEGREE slope! /forums/images/graemlins/shocked.gif At least not sideways. Are you sure about the angle? 35 percent and 35 degrees are not the same thing.

The BX feels more stable on a side slope than a B series. I am certain about that. Whether it is or not is another question that is harder to find the answer to.

I doubt this post is helping you much, but if you want to mow 35 degree slopes I think you better keep what works for you now or get something designed to do steep slope mowing.

The 3PH backhoe is more of a pain to get off and put on the tractor than a four point like on the BX...but it is not that bad after you get used to it. I have a 3pt backhoe and while I like the BH75 or the BX23 backhoe type better, I don't like them enough to want to trade my tractor in to get one.

Besides larger capacity and more power...I don't think a larger tractor adds much else...more backhoe reach would be something else...you always want more reach and more loader power and so on.

35 degrees are steep...really steep...be careful...
 
   / BX23 or B2630? #6  
I think you should go with the 2630 over the BX23. As somebody who owns a BX23 (and only have 1/2 acre to deal with) I think you will find there will be a lot of jobs on that 6 acre parcel that you will go to tackle and find you wish you had more digging capacity on both the FEL and the backhoe if you go with the BX23. From your description it sounds like you want to tackle a decent amount of "terrain reconstruction" so more capacity on the FEL will come in useful. As far as the CAT1 3pt setup it will be a little easier to handle larger implements with the 2630 - although I have found CAt1 implements ( at least the ones I have used ) work OK on the BX23.
 
   / BX23 or B2630? #7  
I changed my BX23 for a B3030 this spring. A B3030 has a more powerful FEL and backhoe. There's a big difference between those two. The BH75 is great (180 degrees swing arc over 140 for a BX23, more reach, more power). The FEL is about twice stronger on a B3030 than a BX23. But to really feel the difference you have to try both. I did... and I changed.

I loved my former BX23 but you'll find the limit of the machine very quickly.

Tough choice you have to make... good luck
 
   / BX23 or B2630? #8  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( I’m stuck deciding between tractors, the BX 23 TLB with 60 in MMM and the B2630 LA403/BH75 with a 60in MMM.

. . .

This is probably the last tractor I will ever buy.

Thanks MBCF)</font>

Just re-read your post. Your last line </font><font color="blue" class="small">( This is probably the last tractor I will ever buy)</font> is the tip off to go for the bigger unit. I have seen lots of posts here on TBN about folks wishing they had gotten a bigger tractor, and except for folks that have a BIG ag tractor, I haven't see a post where somebody wished they had bought a smaller tractor.
 
   / BX23 or B2630?
  • Thread Starter
#9  
Well, the slope is "about" 35 degrees. Measured it once with a level, protractor and a stick. I have considered putting in a rope tow for skiing but dodging the blueberry bushes at the bottom is dicey at best and if you run out too far you’re in the gully, Yahoo! When I mow with the LX 175 going up is no problem , I turn at the top and run down and even in the lowest gear it can be exciting.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

24ft Corral Panels w/ a 10ft Gate (A49251)
24ft Corral Panels...
Kubota BX25D 4WD Tractor Loader Backhoe (A49251)
Kubota BX25D 4WD...
20Yd Roll-Off Dumpster (A49346)
20Yd Roll-Off...
4 New Toyo Tires 205/60/16 (A47371)
4 New Toyo Tires...
TPM 16 Mini Excavator (A49251)
TPM 16 Mini...
2006 PETERBILT 357 (INOPERABLE) (A48992)
2006 PETERBILT 357...
 
Top