I have been thoroughly enjoying this thread. While there wasn't any new insight, it was good to see how people responded to these shows.
See, I make my living as a producer. So does my wife. She has a reality show on TV as we speak, we will see if it gets picked up for next year or not. We are also currently developing another show for another network as well. It won't be mindless but at the end of the day drama makes tv so we will have to have some drama. I make most of my money from movies and tv commercials but have done reality in the past (Biker Build Off was one), but the business model is changing, and there are less movies being made and more tv shows, including reality tv.
I could add a lot to this subject, but it is not necessary. A few things I would say, I don't defend any of the shows in terms of quality or merit, but I wil defend to my dying breath the right for them to be on the air. Hollywood is very sensitive to the viewer, because at the end of the day, if you are not watching we aren't making money. It blows my mind what people watch (I am not being highbrow, I love robot chicken) but at the end of the day there is enough of an audience for advertisers to buy space so the shows keep getting made. I don't think there are too many people in hollywood who would not like to see reality tv go the way of the dodo bird, but that is not what audiences want right now. A deep look at socio economic pressures reveals a lot, and how people look to entertainment and what types of entertainment for escape. Maybe as the economy shifts people will not need to see people less fortunate than them, and will be looking for escape in the way of comedies (what ever happened to sitcoms?) or just 2 hours in a movie theater watching something more than explosions and shaky camera shots.
All the best
Carl Beyer