I have carried a tool bag with ratchet tie downs and ropes in my pickup trucks for the last 40 years or so. I generally choose rope as faster and easier. Tie downs are too much hassle to arrange, work, and store. I seldom use them. I also see them along the road when they loosen, flap, and the shallow hooks let go. I spend way too much frustrating time monkeying with them and wrapping them up to put a rubber band around them. Then the rubber decays and they end up tangled. Ropes don't do that. The trick with ropes is finding good quality rope, which in my case is braided nylon, cutting it into convenient lengths about 15 to 20 feet, and burning the ends to prevent fraying. If you leave a rope 50 or 100 feet it will guarantee a headache and tangle. A few months ago I got some new rope and made some lengths up to replace missing ones - most of which I gave away to folks needing them, and some which were wearing out. I had to shop a long time for quality rope. Skip TSC, Home Depot, Lowes, etc. as I shopped there and for this purpose their rope is NFG. A lot of modern rope has a solid cotton core and it is NFG for this purpose. Also, do not buy twisted strand rope - it does not lay or drape well. I ended up ordering it online, and I think it was 5/16". As soon as I remove a rope to store it I coil it and bind it with the last few lashes - just like my Dad did. It takes about 10 seconds, never tangles, and is instantly available when needed. He learned to handle ropes in the Signal Core US Army and at NJ Ma Bell. I learned from him. It is interesting that the original thread author ended up completely opposite on this choice. Shows how different folks are, and we are free to do as we please. I have good quality ratchet straps of different sizes and I still don't use them. I should start giving them away but I want people to arrive home without incident, so I give them rope.