Advice request from mechanical engineers

/ Advice request from mechanical engineers #21  
As far as why the recommended load is so low for rod, I think a major concern is notch toughness.

The simple design of threaded rod means the entire length is subjecting the rod to looking like it is notched.
A notched piece of steel is simply going to offer less strength than a smooth piece of steel.
The "notch", which in this case is the threads, causes localized stress risers to occur.

You calculate the stress based on the root diameter of the threaded rod, and come up with "X"

Then, when the notch raises the stress locally,, there is some design factor that will reduce "X".

Cheapo threaded rod looks like the threads were created with a dull hatchet.
The cracks at the root of the threads could not be worse.
So, also, since the cracks that are threads are so bad, the notch stress increase is maximized.

The cheapo threaded rod could be greatly strengthened by sand-blasting the root of the threads to eliminate all of the locations where the stress is increased.

The threads could be roll formed into the rod.

These things are not done,, the usable load of the rod is simply reduced.
 

Marketplace Items

2011 CIRCLE M  35 GOOSENECK (A60736)
2011 CIRCLE M 35...
Crown RM6025-45 4,500 LB Stand-On Electric Forklift (A59228)
Crown RM6025-45...
2009 Arco Trailer 6,000 Gallon T/A Tank Trailer (A61568)
2009 Arco Trailer...
500 BBL FRAC TANK (A58214)
500 BBL FRAC TANK...
2018 Komatsu D61PX Crawler Tractor Dozer (A59228)
2018 Komatsu D61PX...
Pat's QH and hydraulic top-link.
Pat's QH and...
 
Top