Seems like my search for a tractor is coming down to a decision between a new 2615-gear and 3215-gear. I had pretty much settled on the 2615 - like the larger size and loader compared to the 2015. Wife saw a 3215 - she likes the new styling etc of the 3215, plus we both like the larger volume bucket size. Are some minor diffs - turbo engine, diff gear transmissions. General question I have is that is the 3125 be a better value for the an extra $2400? Either would fill the bill nicely for me. Thanks much for any and all input.
2615 vs 3215
- Thread starter GLLinMO
- Start date
- Views: 4372
bkheur
Silver Member
Like you I also compare the 2615 to the 3215. I liked the shuttle shift on the 3215 and the higher HP. But in the end I went with the 2615 gear.
It has done everything I need to do, most things I want to do, and somethings I am surprised that it did.
I have had mine since August 2007 and almost have 100 hrs on it. No real problems or issues so far.
I have used a plow (2 bottom), 7ft disc, 5ft bush hog, have pulled a 7ft grader blade ( I like the 5ft I have now better), and cut a whole bunch of fire wood. FEL has been strong enough, but a little more capacity would never hurt.
In the end it came down to my Budget and I could not spend the extra $2500
I think either one will serve you well (2615 or 3215)
It has done everything I need to do, most things I want to do, and somethings I am surprised that it did.
I have had mine since August 2007 and almost have 100 hrs on it. No real problems or issues so far.
I have used a plow (2 bottom), 7ft disc, 5ft bush hog, have pulled a 7ft grader blade ( I like the 5ft I have now better), and cut a whole bunch of fire wood. FEL has been strong enough, but a little more capacity would never hurt.
In the end it came down to my Budget and I could not spend the extra $2500
I think either one will serve you well (2615 or 3215)
Attachments
bill6
Silver Member
Hi GLL, 16 months ago I was in your situation. I compared carefully, and ended up getting the 3215 gear. I like the much newer styling and modern instrument panel. And the rubber floor deck mat. The ML 111 loader has larger cylinders and will lift substantially more weight.
If you are planning on using any implements that use the rear PTO, such as a bush hog (field & brush mower) or tiller, the 3215 has significantly more PTO horsepower. Also, that extra power was well used when I was pulling a heavy disk harrow in soft ground.
The 3215 was an excellent machine for me. I kept it for one year, then traded it on a new 2415 gear, I needed a smaller tractor.
If you are planning on using any implements that use the rear PTO, such as a bush hog (field & brush mower) or tiller, the 3215 has significantly more PTO horsepower. Also, that extra power was well used when I was pulling a heavy disk harrow in soft ground.
The 3215 was an excellent machine for me. I kept it for one year, then traded it on a new 2415 gear, I needed a smaller tractor.
Sergei
Gold Member
Have you looked at the 2815HST, it has the same body but without the turbo cost. Also have you and your wife gone to a dealer and test driven either tractor, the HST is by far the better tractor than a gear one, I'll never go back to gear. The big thing is your wife may even like the way the tractor operates, but the downside is you may have trouble getting the tractor away from her!
The 2815HST is about $500 less than the 3215 gear. Dealer does not have a 2815 in stock - so I cannot test drive one. (all he has is 3215G and 2615G). Maybe I should look into it.
Question - on the 2815 HST - how is the trans controlled - foot or lever. To me the foot controls are a pain.
Do appreciate the comments - That's why I asked. Gary
Question - on the 2815 HST - how is the trans controlled - foot or lever. To me the foot controls are a pain.
Do appreciate the comments - That's why I asked. Gary
Sergei
Gold Member
GLLinMO said:
The trans control is mounted on the left fender and has three positions, High,Medium and Low. The right floor area has the HST pedals which controls the forward and reverse movement, it has two separate pedals. and not a center pivot point like some other tractors (Kioti).
Also where are you located, maybe other members can help point to a dealer with a better price, it seem 500 isn't much of a price break between the two models. Also I've posted pictures of my tractor under other threads which might help you.
Dealer i am looking at is a very local dealer - about 2 miles from my house. Definetely an "old school" dealer - like what I worked with back in the 70's. Seems like a nice guy to work with, and my limited comparisons seem to indacte the prices are atr least "fair" - probably not bottom dollar.
He does not have 2815 HST in stock, and for the "price diff: he compared the MSRP between the 2815hst and 3215 gear (both use the same loader).
I dunno - I could go either way between those two. 2615 probably the better buy for me. Need to do a test drive when the weahter clears.
Would like to see a Massey 1528 - but there is not a dealer close.
He does not have 2815 HST in stock, and for the "price diff: he compared the MSRP between the 2815hst and 3215 gear (both use the same loader).
I dunno - I could go either way between those two. 2615 probably the better buy for me. Need to do a test drive when the weahter clears.
Would like to see a Massey 1528 - but there is not a dealer close.
bindian
Super Member
GLLinMo,GLLinMO said:
What is your major use for the tractor to be bought? Mowing, plowing, general loader work? All else being equal........nothing beats cubic inches
and the heavier the tractor, the better for dirt work. hugs, Brandi
PBinWA
Platinum Member
- Joined
- Jun 10, 2004
- Messages
- 906
- Location
- WA
- Tractor
- Kioti NX55, Mahindra 2615, Case 36CXB, Case W4, Volvo MC85C
Your crazy to not spend the extra $2400 and get the better machine. When I was shopping $2400 would have got me a 3015 HST which was not really that much more tractor than the 2615 gear considering that I was concerned with PTO HP and weight. The loader on the 2615 is a little weak. I am considering upgrading to a 3215 in the future since the extra HP and better loader are definitly the weak points on the 2615.
However, if you don't plan to lift much with your loader and you don't expect to need to mow really thick grass/hay then the 2615 is "good enough".
However, if you don't plan to lift much with your loader and you don't expect to need to mow really thick grass/hay then the 2615 is "good enough".
Again, appreciate the input. Main uses will be mowing 4 acres pastrure a few times a year, routine grading of corrals and small arena, and loader work to move manure semi routnely. An probably once or twice a year, I get a load of gravel screenings and move it around with a loader (rented tractor).
No doubt the 2615 is enough. Questioin is - for $2500 more, should I go with the 3215? In part, more power and capabilities (marginal and not really needed) plus I do like the new platform of the 3215. On one hand, $2500 is a significant chunk, on the other hand if I am spending $14K plus, make sure I get "what I want".
Now, if we get more land in the future - would like to but not sure if or when - bigger may help out.
Some time this week need to stop by dealer and "test drive". Will bring wife - she's always a fan of bigger/newer.
Also begs the question - if I consider a 3215 - the Kubota L3400 is pretty much the same price. Would that make sense? (Do like the Mahindra better) - but is orange better for resale? I know I know - don't worry about that, buy what you wnat.
No doubt the 2615 is enough. Questioin is - for $2500 more, should I go with the 3215? In part, more power and capabilities (marginal and not really needed) plus I do like the new platform of the 3215. On one hand, $2500 is a significant chunk, on the other hand if I am spending $14K plus, make sure I get "what I want".
Now, if we get more land in the future - would like to but not sure if or when - bigger may help out.
Some time this week need to stop by dealer and "test drive". Will bring wife - she's always a fan of bigger/newer.
Also begs the question - if I consider a 3215 - the Kubota L3400 is pretty much the same price. Would that make sense? (Do like the Mahindra better) - but is orange better for resale? I know I know - don't worry about that, buy what you wnat.
bindian
Super Member
GllinMO,GLLinMO said:
If you will be working alot in and around the corral and esecially a barn, smaller may be better. A bigger machine in a barn can be like a bull in a china closet.
hugs, Brandi
Nice weather today - went for some test drives at my local Mahindra dealer.
First off, I decided I could not jsutify the extra $$$ for the 3215. So I drove a 2615. Nice tractor. Clutch not the most convenient - arc of clutch pedal is "out". But, plenty of room in the cockpit. Overall, what I expected. It will work.
Then I sit on the 3215. more room at the seat. Clutch pedal goes down - a much more natural stroke, and less effort too. I do like the mat - I know - not a big deal. Dealer says let me get a key. So I drive it. Really love the synchro on the for the forward - reverse on the trans. Overall - I love it.
So - Do I really want to spend the extra for the $$$ 3215? Looking that way.
Also - stopped by the second location of the local Deere - kubota dealer. Again looked at the L2800. Nice tractor. better price than the first location. More $$$ than the 2615 gear - but probably worth it. But still not the chocie compared to the 3215. (And the 3215 has that cute little turbo).
Let's see what Santa decides on.....................
First off, I decided I could not jsutify the extra $$$ for the 3215. So I drove a 2615. Nice tractor. Clutch not the most convenient - arc of clutch pedal is "out". But, plenty of room in the cockpit. Overall, what I expected. It will work.
Then I sit on the 3215. more room at the seat. Clutch pedal goes down - a much more natural stroke, and less effort too. I do like the mat - I know - not a big deal. Dealer says let me get a key. So I drive it. Really love the synchro on the for the forward - reverse on the trans. Overall - I love it.
So - Do I really want to spend the extra for the $$$ 3215? Looking that way.
Also - stopped by the second location of the local Deere - kubota dealer. Again looked at the L2800. Nice tractor. better price than the first location. More $$$ than the 2615 gear - but probably worth it. But still not the chocie compared to the 3215. (And the 3215 has that cute little turbo).
Let's see what Santa decides on.....................
DavesTractor
Elite Member
The 2615 uses a two-stage clutch, and the travel portion (the PTO is the first stage) of the clutch is the second stage, that is why the tractor does not start moving until the clutch is raised a little higher. The 3215 has a single stage clutch which feels different....better in my opinion.
Spend the extra $$, get what you want, you will have it for decades.
Spend the extra $$, get what you want, you will have it for decades.
GLLinMO said:
