Charities, good and bad from a disaster area.

   / Charities, good and bad from a disaster area. #21  
Only between 3-4% of donations to the American Red Cross are used for Administration. The CEO makes about 700k. In comparison, United Way Worldwide uses about 2-3% of its donations for administration and the CEO makes about 1.2million. Numbers for United Way are distorted though since most local work is done through local organizations that are separate 501(c)3 orgs, and thus report on different forms.

Red Cross gets a lot of flak because they never guarantee that donations go directly to any one specific need. They will tell you that if you ask, and they have gotten better about not implying it (they really got stuck when they collected money after Katrina). That doesn't mean that they don't do a lot of good, but I think you probably have better places to give to disaster relief.

We usually give to the Churches of Christ Disaster Relief Effort since their only thing is disaster relief. I've worked hands on with them before and they do good things. https://www.disasterreliefeffort.org/
 
   / Charities, good and bad from a disaster area. #22  
When I worked at Savannah River Plant we were browbeat into donating to United Way. It was whispered that you would get less of a raise or get passed on a promotion if you did not donate. Their goal was always 100% participation. I read a lot about them and didn't want to give them my money. Then in the midst of one of the drives some of their top brass got popped for stealing money. That ended the SRP 100% participation program. I don't give to charities, ytere's no such thing as a charity. We have a local orphanage that needs all the help they can get. And then there's St Jude.
 
   / Charities, good and bad from a disaster area.
  • Thread Starter
#23  
I think that one of the most selfless that you can do for the good of your community is to donate blood. If you can, you should be donating blood. Communities run short of blood all the time, but especially around the holidays when there are more accidents. Most people have no idea how much blood an accident victim needs or how critical the blood need is for babies, or liver transplants which go through enormous amounts.

I hope that you, your family, and friends never need blood. Anyone being transfused is in dire straights. People on the verge of dying routinely try anything to stave off death, no matter the expense. Be thankful that blood is donated by millions of people so others whom they don't know can have a shot at survival, having a brain, being able to survive cancer treatment or get a donated organ. Blood can be purchased, but all things being equal local blood is preferred to blood that has to be air freighted from fill in the blank country.

If you go back and read my original post you will see that I said the blood donation group is separate from the disaster relief group. I donate blood and platelets thru the Red Cross. Not as often as I should but still fairly often. They serve a necessary purpose and I do not care if they make a profit on their work. It takes a lot of money to run the donation centers and distribute the porduct.

RSKY
 
   / Charities, good and bad from a disaster area. #24  
My father was in WWll. He never had a good word to say about the Red Cross. There are plenty of local organizations that I do contribute to.
I remember back when I was a little tyke, right after WWII one of my parent's friends, who was in Italy during WWII, cursing the Red Cross. He said he stood in line, nearly an hour, in the cold and rain, to get a cup of hot coffee from them. He said when he finally got up to the coffee stand, they were charging the GI's and he didn't have a dime on him.
 
   / Charities, good and bad from a disaster area. #25  
Other the other hand .... In at least some major cities SA shows up to fire and other disaster scenes in a mobile canteen that distributes food and drinks to responders with never a mention of money. I don't know if they collect anything from the cities later.

The Salvation Army Supports Responders During Boston ...
Salvation Army dispatches emergency canteen trucks to ...
 
   / Charities, good and bad from a disaster area. #26  
I don't think anyone has mentioned Rotary International. Check it out here on CharityWatch. https://www.charitywatch.org/charities/rotary-foundation-of-rotary-international

And here on Charity Navigator, https://www.charitynavigator.org/ein/363245072

I have been a member of several Rotary Clubs over the past 25 years. Rotary does wonderful things in local communities and around the world. If you are looking for a charity, I strongly suggest you consider Rotary. And, if you are looking to do some community volunteering, I strongly suggest you consider joining your local Rotary Club. Besides doing lots of good in the community and world, you will get to meet lots of really good people and have lots of fun.
 
   / Charities, good and bad from a disaster area. #27  
If you go back and read my original post you will see that I said the blood donation group is separate from the disaster relief group. I donate blood and platelets thru the Red Cross. Not as often as I should but still fairly often. They serve a necessary purpose and I do not care if they make a profit on their work. It takes a lot of money to run the donation centers and distribute the porduct.

RSKY
The American Red Cross is one organization that runs both a blood bank an a disaster relief organization. It isn't separate. Also, they don't profit on blood donations. They charge for them to pay for the operating costs of the entire organization
 
   / Charities, good and bad from a disaster area.
  • Thread Starter
#28  
At church today they mentioned another charity that the elders worked with and highly recommend. Actually, next week's entire contribution will be donated to Mercy Chefs. I had never heard of them but they came to Mayfield, set up, and cooked meals for anybody that needed or wanted one. They did this quietly and without any publicity. They have just recently left the area. The donation next week will help them set up MORE camps in Poland and the Ukraine to feed refugees.

RSKY
 
   / Charities, good and bad from a disaster area.
  • Thread Starter
#29  
The American Red Cross is one organization that runs both a blood bank an a disaster relief organization. It isn't separate. Also, they don't profit on blood donations. They charge for them to pay for the operating costs of the entire organization

All I know about them is that the people working at the blood donation center I go to said that they were in an entirely different organization from the disaster relief group. They all work for Red Cross but more like different companies owned by an umbrella holding company. I am repeating what they told me and they work for the Red Cross.

RSKY
 
   / Charities, good and bad from a disaster area. #30  
...
Good: Samaritans Purse is #1. Head and shoulders above the rest. They arrived in town two days after the tornado and crews are still here. They work hard, are very respectful, and did I say that they work hard while seeming to have a good time. Attitude us everything. The Mennonites also showed up a couple days after the event and are still working. They are a smaller group, not as obvious, and worked mainly on getting damaged homes livable and still have a smaller presence here. Bread of Life is a local charity. They are a smaller group but have done amazing work. Their distribution efforts were better organized than anybody else's. If you search Bread of Life several groups will come up but the local one is a Church of Christ group located in Graves County. They were literally first on the scene in events that took place within a hundred miles of here before the December tornado. All of these are groups that are affiliated with religious organizations and use volunteers and donations.
...
This was my experience after Hurricane Floyd. I don't know where the Mennonites came from, I did find out years later, they do have a community in the NC mountains, but they were on the ground working before the flood waters had receded. They impressed the heck out of me. The Baptists were also in the flooded out areas early. The Mennonites came in with their people, hand tools and that was it but very welcome. The Baptists did the same but they also had a semi trailer that as a combination kitchen and bathhouse. Both groups were in it for the long haul.

As the flood was receding, the Mennonites were starting to work already gathering and sorting supplies for the local people. The NC National Guard was in town with a mobile kitchen feeding locals and volunteers. You needed food, you got it. The Red Cross was driving around in panel truck handing out foam containers of pasta. A week or two later I want back to help with the clean up and the National Guard and Red Cross was gone. The Mennonites were still there and the Baptists had joined them. They were there for the long haul and were helping clean out flood damaged houses, strip the walls and floors to the studs/joist and rebuild.

Years after Floyd, a storm front went through dropping tornadoes here and there. On tornado hit a three homes, one of which was a family member of a coworker. The coworker's family member was killed as was one of their neighbors. We went to help clean up and save what could be saved. Not much was worth saving but we were there mostly to show support to the family. For them, just having a bunch of strangers show up, to go through the rubble pile and find photos and such was a great help to them. I found a photo from one of the other houses that was destroyed, and a man killed, that was hundreds of yards away from us. The photo was in a field that I somehow saw and I took it to the other family. The photo was one of the few images they had of another family member that had died years before. I did many things that day that made the trip and work worth the effort, but finding that photo in the middle of a field was made the whole effort worth while. It was like finding a big pot of gold. The family cried when I walked up with that photo. Now, the point of this story is that there was no national organization out there helping. None. Zippo. Nobody was there be locals or people who knew the families affected. However, the next day, a bus load or two of people were trying down from VA to help clean up. I don't know why the church was sending people but they were.

The irony is that if the tornado had been a hundred yards or so east or west, it would have missed those three homes...

We had a TBN discussion years ago on where to donate money. What I took from that discussion, and my experience, is to give as local as one can.

Later,
Dan
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2019 CATERPILLAR 326FL EXCAVATOR (A51242)
2019 CATERPILLAR...
UNUSED CFG Industrial XZ20R Mini Excavator (A47384)
UNUSED CFG...
2013 VOLVO VNL860 TANDEM AXLE SLEEPER (A51219)
2013 VOLVO VNL860...
Quick Attach Hydro Slide Pallet Forks (A50514)
Quick Attach Hydro...
66in Light Material Bucket Skid Steer Connection (A52128)
66in Light...
2014 PETERSON 4700B HORIZONTAL GRINDER (A51242)
2014 PETERSON...
 
Top