Help me decide which backhoe to keep.

[ARinKS]

What is a better backhoe to keep for farm use?

- case 580ck or a Massey Ferguson 40B??

Both are around the same age. And both in decent condition.
I just need one. The case is gas, I am fine with that though. The Massey is in a little better shape.

Does anyone have any hands on experience with one or the other?

 

[goeduck]

Case backhoes are legendary but that Massey 40b has 3 point capability at least on some models. Do you have the 3 pt setup for when the backhoe is off? The Massey has a Perkins engine so that is good. The Case is gas, I would not favor that.

 

[scaredychicken]

I know nothing about backhoes, but all things being equal ... I would keep the one that is in better shape / condition. (Massey, as you indicated).

 

[jcbGM]

I️ say keep whichever you can still get parts for, which I️ would believe is the case.

 

[ARinKS]

Some good points guys.
Both of these units are industrial units that do not have rear PTO. I suppose the question is is a case 580ck that's gas better than a MF with a Perkins. All things considered.

 

[fried1765]

Some good points guys.
Both of these units are industrial units that do not have rear PTO. I suppose the question is is a case 580ck that's gas better than a MF with a Perkins. All things considered.

I have a (1970) Ford 3400 quick disconnect TLB (with 3pt hitch). It is probably of similar vintage to your two choices.
You don't mention the comparative number of engine hours.
I love my 44HP gas Ford. It is now 47 years old, with 1850 hours..
The Perkins engine in the Massey is certainly a plus. What engine (gas) does the 380CK have?
How many hours on each machine?

 

[KYErik]

If you plan to use it a lot- then the diesel might represent a $ savings on fuel but might be more difficult to start in winter unless you have a block heater. I have an old Case 530 diesel backhoe that I use maybe on average 5 hours per year. It is very handy, but I really wish it was not an industrial unit (it has no PTO) so I could detach the hoe and use it more for farm work (use the loader for moving round bales, running the grain auger, etc.).

If you haven't purchased it yet- would you consider a 3 point unit? (and use it gently to avoid overloading/damaging the tractor/3 point) At the time I bought mine, I didn't have a large enough tractor to attach a 3 point unit to, but now that I do, and no more often that I use it, I would probably prefer a 3 point unit.

 

[goeduck]

I would go Massey.

 

[Streetcar]

I️ say keep whichever you can still get parts for, which I️ would believe is the case.

Is Massey still supported with parts

 

[DJ54]

At least for my area, Massey Industrial parts are pretty hard to find. I did have a Case 310B several years back, and really had no problem finding most parts, even though some were from salvage machines. I have a 480C now, and can find anything I've needed so far. Lots of quality aftermarket items out there now, plus a lot of salvage items for the Case machines, which would be my biggest concern for an older machine.

 

[ARinKS]

Actually I would prefer a Ford over either the Massey Ferguson or the Case.
But I am like another poster and just don't use the unit much. Maybe 40 hours a year.
As far as hours no idea. These are old and we'll worn so the hours gauges are shot. On the case there are no working interments. But I am fine with that. I am.the only one use it and if there is a low oil pressure issue I will hear it.
I suppose I'll keep the old case and perhaps watch for a more modern unit in the future.
Thank you for the comments and ideas.