Trailer Purchase Decision Advice

/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice #1  

gocards1177

Gold Member
Joined
Jun 4, 2011
Messages
423
Location
Rolla, MO
I drive a 2011 Tundra Double cab. It's rated for towing about 9K. A trailer large enough to haul my tractor would require a new truck, so I'm not looking for that as a use. This trailer will be general use - for chores around our property (like hauling limbs), transporting landscaping stuff (like mulch), and trips to and from the local lumberyard and St. Louis (100 miles of interstate) for building materials when we build our house. After borrowing a friend's 16' tandem car hauler a few times, I'm ready to buy something of my own and after reading through the different threads here on trailer sizes, and I think for my needs a 6' x 10'/12' single axle is the best fit. I like the flat bed trailers rather than the ones with sides. I've been watching craigslist/searchtempest and I haven't seen anything that catches my eye. I'm leaning towards new because I'm afraid of what unknown abuse has been done to something used. I've considered a dump trailer, but boy they're expensive! I like the size of this trailer matched to my truck, and it would be simpler to attach.

I drove to three different places near me to look at what's available. Two were dealers - a "premium" and "bargain" place. One was a local manufacturer. I tried to compare apples to apples.

The first stop was the premium dealer. They had a Rice trailer, asking $1863! He said it weighs about 1200#. It had lights built into the frame, powder coating all around including the bottom, D-rings inside, and a lock box on the tongue. Available tomorrow. IMG_1375.jpg

Next I went to the discount place. They had a generic "utility trailer" fo r$785. It was OK, but had used tires, no paint/lots of rust underneath, overspray on decking, and looked sloppy overall. Available now.

Last I went to the manufacturer. Great impression with owner and overall business. They could build a flat bed trailer 10 ' for $940 or 12' for $980. He said it weighs about 800#. I couldn't see it since it wasn't built, but looking at their other trailers they had, looked to be a good compromise between the other two places. I took a picture of a similar trailer, but it was a tandem and a picture of a picture of a previous trailer similar to what I want. Their lead time to deliver is "about 3 weeks". Some upgrade options to consider with them would be painting the underside $50, building a lockbox $depends on size, upgrading to a 5200 axle $300, or tandem axle $520. I would build a simple, removable wood slat sides/front/back myself.
IMG_1378.jpgIMG_1376.jpg

My gut tells me the last place is the way to go. I'm confused now on the axle though and I can't decide what's right.
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice #2  
You are in the right area for trailers. Sikeston Mo is trailer capital of the world. Take a trip down there and look.

In the end buy once, buy right, and go with your gut.

Being a trailer dealer I would never sell a single longer than 12' and never a axle above 3500# for a single.

Chris
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice
  • Thread Starter
#3  
You are in the right area for trailers. Sikeston Mo is trailer capital of the world. Take a trip down there and look.

In the end buy once, buy right, and go with your gut.

Being a trailer dealer I would never sell a single longer than 12' and never a axle above 3500# for a single.

Chris

Sikeston is 3.5 hours away. I don't mind making phone calls but do you really think its going to make a price/quality difference enough to make a 7 hour round trip worthwhile? Do you know specifically who I should call in sikeston? Otherwise I can just google it.
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice #4  
Sikeston is 3.5 hours away. I don't mind making phone calls but do you really think its going to make a price/quality difference enough to make a 7 hour round trip worthwhile? Do you know specifically who I should call in sikeston? Otherwise I can just google it.

I have bought from Jerry Jones. Google Sikeston Trailer and you will find tons of manufacturers.

I drive 12 hours round trip from Indiana because its worth it.

Chris
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice
  • Thread Starter
#5  
I have bought from Jerry Jones. Google Sikeston Trailer and you will find tons of manufacturers.

I drive 12 hours round trip from Indiana because its worth it.

Chris

Do you mean jerry james?
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice #6  
A nice feature to have is the ability to fold the tailgate forward onto the deck of the trailer, Even tho its mesh it still has a ton of drag that you can eliminate when towing it empty.
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice
  • Thread Starter
#8  
Sorry, that's it. Stupid spell check.

Ill call jerry James tomorrow and see how they compare.

The "premium" trailer I looked at had the gate that folded forward. Otherwise I was going to go with no gate. Since this is light duty I would make some ramps with 2 bys and angle iron when needed.
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice #9  
car hauler with 2 -5200 lb axles, 16" 10 ply tires and have a tie down rail added down each side in front and behind the fenders and a full wrap tongue.
I had one like that for 10-12 yrs and ran the wheels off it. just sold it and went to a 12k trailer
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice
  • Thread Starter
#10  
car hauler with 2 -5200 lb axles, 16" 10 ply tires and have a tie down rail added down each side in front and behind the fenders and a full wrap tongue.
I had one like that for 10-12 yrs and ran the wheels off it. just sold it and went to a 12k trailer

That sounds nice but is more than I want. I want something quick to attach and good for general chores.
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice #11  
That sounds nice but is more than I want. I want something quick to attach and good for general chores.

I was looking to do most of the same chores as you are. Like you my truck is to small to haul my tractor, so that wasn't part of the plain. Here is what I decided on, and has been working out well for me. 14ft bed 6ft between the fenders, tandem 3,500lbs axles, the deck is 5/4 PT, weight is 1,440lbs.
I prefer having tandem axles and brakes hauling lumber.
I haven't built sideboards yet, but plain to in the future.New 14 ft Trailer 002.jpg
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice
  • Thread Starter
#12  
I was looking to do most of the same chores as you are. Like you my truck is to small to haul my tractor, so that wasn't part of the plain. Here is what I decided on, and has been working out well for me. 14ft bed 6ft between the fenders, tandem 3,500lbs axles, the deck is 5/4 PT, weight is 1,440lbs.
I prefer having tandem axles and brakes hauling lumber.
I haven't built sideboards yet, but plain to in the future.<img src="http://www.tractorbynet.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=326982"/>

That's sharp looking. Is the tandem axle/14 footer easy to hook up? I'd like to pull my truck near and just lift the tongue right onto the ball by hand. My friend's 16 foot tandem is too big for that.
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice #13  
That's sharp looking. Is the tandem axle/14 footer easy to hook up? I'd like to pull my truck near and just lift the tongue right onto the ball by hand. My friend's 16 foot tandem is too big for that.

Thank you. Lift it by hand? Maybe 20 years ago, but now I use the tongue jack.:laughing:
I built the trailer 14ft for two reasons. (1) I felt that I would need to haul 14-16ft pcs of lumber. (2) the 5in channel I had was 14ft long, and I hate to waste.:)

I was on the fence about making it 12ft, and honestly I think it would work OK too.

Even at 12ft I would want tandem axles.:thumbsup:

I have seen factory built trailers similar to mine. Trailers | Utility | Tandem Axle | Medium Duty | towiing | hauling and I'm sure there are others.

Bill
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice #14  
You are in the right area for trailers. Sikeston Mo is trailer capital of the world. Take a trip down there and look.

In the end buy once, buy right, and go with your gut.

Being a trailer dealer I would never sell a single longer than 12' and never a axle above 3500# for a single.

Chris

Why?

I have a 6.5 x 12' tilt, with a 6K single axle that is very handy.
P6250010.JPG P6250012.JPG P3300135.JPGP3300137.JPG

Even hauled my old tractor on it, back in the day. :D
P3310002.JPG P3310004.JPG P3310005.jpg P3310007.jpg
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice #15  
A single that out weighs a tow vehicle. Been there done that. I won't sell or tow them anymore. Just hope you never have a blow out at 65mph with a single axle trailer loaded to 6K.

Chris
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice #16  
A single that out weighs a tow vehicle. Been there done that. I won't sell or tow them anymore. Just hope you never have a blow out at 65mph with a single axle trailer loaded to 6K.

Chris

My 3/4 ton GMC Duramax weighs 7300, front axle 4100, rear axle 3200. The empty weight on the trailer axle is 1660 lbs, tires are rated at 3640 lbs. each. So I have no qualms pulling it.

I have had blowouts on a single axle horse trailer, but it was a gooseneck, so no problem.
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice #17  
My 3/4 ton GMC Duramax weighs 7300, front axle 4100, rear axle 3200. The empty weight on the trailer axle is 1660 lbs, tires are rated at 3640 lbs. each. So I have no qualms pulling it.

I have had blowouts on a single axle horse trailer, but it was a gooseneck, so no problem.

To each his own. I tow about 10000 miles a year and even with my 7600 lb F350 I would not want a single that high. I tow as much as 25000 lbs with my truck but that is a tri axle.

Chris
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice #18  
Ill call jerry James tomorrow and see how they compare.

The "premium" trailer I looked at had the gate that folded forward. Otherwise I was going to go with no gate. Since this is light duty I would make some ramps with 2 bys and angle iron when needed.
Someone else had posted on here about another dealer in Sikeston, Retco Trailers.

Look here: http://www.tractorbynet.com/forums/...elp-needed-trailer-options-2.html#post3201653

They seemed to be quite satisfied. Of course, the lower the price of trailers you're looking at the less it pays to go riding around for hours.
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice
  • Thread Starter
#19  
Someone else had posted on here about another dealer in Sikeston, Retco Trailers.

Look here: http://www.tractorbynet.com/forums/trailers-transportation/271482-help-needed-trailer-options-2.html#post3201653

They seemed to be quite satisfied. Of course, the lower the price of trailers you're looking at the less it pays to go riding around for hours.

That's my thoughts too. Diminishing returns at this price point. I never got around to calling today. I seem to change my opinion day to day. Wondering now if I should go bigger and tandem axle to max out what my truck could do. And possibly used since I'm not in a rush.
 
/ Trailer Purchase Decision Advice #20  
I recommend SearchTempest for craigslist. you can set a radius of cities to search.

There are always a lot of trailers listed around here.
 

Marketplace Items

2015 Ford Fusion Hybrid Sedan (A59231)
2015 Ford Fusion...
2017 Ford F-150 4x4 Ext. Cab Pickup Truck (A59230)
2017 Ford F-150...
2015 Volvo VNL 64T (A55315)
2015 Volvo VNL 64T...
2017 Ford Transit 350 Passenger Van (A59230)
2017 Ford Transit...
2003 TRAIL KING TRI-AXLE BELLY DUMP TRAILER (A58214)
2003 TRAIL KING...
Volvo EC220EL (A60462)
Volvo EC220EL (A60462)
 
Top