Superduties?? talk about the recent models

/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #1  

HCJtractor

Veteran Member
Joined
Jan 28, 2009
Messages
1,541
Location
upstate South Carolina, Greenville
Tractor
Kubota M6800, Massey Ferguson 240
I have a F-350 SRW diesel with 185,000 miles. Only had it for less than two years, but it had high mileage when I bought it. What's the scoop on the newer models? Mine has the infamous 6.0 and I know they have changed engines since. How do the later models compare? I am toying with the idea of trading, but the new sticker price is pretty steep. Are there bargains to be had now? Is Ford dealing on the 2010 or 2011s, or is sticker price standing up. Just curious about the newer ones and what you guys think. I also heard the newer Dodges were nice. (don't want to start a war, just wanted some opinions)
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #2  
I have a F-350 SRW diesel with 185,000 miles. Only had it for less than two years, but it had high mileage when I bought it. What's the scoop on the newer models? Mine has the infamous 6.0 and I know they have changed engines since. How do the later models compare? I am toying with the idea of trading, but the new sticker price is pretty steep. Are there bargains to be had now? Is Ford dealing on the 2010 or 2011s, or is sticker price standing up. Just curious about the newer ones and what you guys think. I also heard the newer Dodges were nice. (don't want to start a war, just wanted some opinions)

You might find some sort of deal on a 2010...as the diesel for that year was the 6.4L...the 2011 models have the new diesel which is a 6.7L...and is newly designed...I know a couple of folks with the 6.4 and they seem to think its a good engine...Myself, I have a '99 F350 SRW with the 7.3 that I don't think I'll be getting rid of any time soon....good luck. BobG in VA
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #3  
I have had three. Two were 6.0L, one a F-250 and one a F-350 SRW. I also had a 7.3L F-350 SRW. All have been great trucks. I have had none of the 6.0L problems so I am still happy.

How has your truck been? That would way heavy on my decison. If I was wanting a Dodge I would find a 06/07 5.9L with a Manual or wait till they get the Aisan tranny in the 3/4 and 1 tons.

Chris
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #4  
I have one of Ford's new 6.7L diesels. These motors are smooth with alot of power. I've been monitoring any issues with these trucks are several forums for months and there really isn't to many "real" down time problems. There are alot of "rough" tranny shifting complaints but most are fixed with a simple computer flash. I don't recall seeing any problems on the 6.7 that the 6.0L and 6.4L's have. For a first year engine and tranny combo, so far Ford has hit a home run IMO.
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #5  
I have a 3/4 ton Dodge with the little 5.9l Cummins and automatic... so far, its been flawless. Mine has been seriously worked and overloaded on many occasions... knock on wood, its never backed away from anything.
There is nothing wrong with the stock automatic in this year of truck IF the enigne is left in stock form. With that said, the transmission will only hold the stock power, add a programmer and start acting 16 years old with it and you might end up at the tranny shop.
Funny thing is, guys that have stuck Allisons behind these trucks realize the same thing... add power to it, and the Allison blows up also. IMHO, its a matter of the little inline engine being able to produce max torque at such a low RPM... the v configuration Ford and Chevy diesels cant. Another reason for no manual trans. offered by GM or Ford.
For the new Fords, so far, I have seen very few failures on the pickups. Seen a few holes in cylinder blocks with rods hanging out, but that can happen with new product development. The C&C 2011 Fords are a different story.... we have lost 4 engines and one transmission...
But, in the end, its what you are most comfortable with, and how much you wanna spend. They ARE EXPENSIVE!!!.. And maintenance costs are higher than ever before on them...
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #6  
Drive a new Ford 6.7 and you will be amazed on a couple of points.
1. The asking price is over the top! but some dealers will work a deal kind of.
2. Performance is unbelivevable out of the box, but you will not find 4.10 gears in the back, or manual transmissions any more....

The 6 speed Auto is pretty tough and from all that I have heard and read it stand up fairly well to 400hp and 800#ft troque. It has 2 OD gears which is kinda cheating to find fuel mileage might not be so great for towing big loads

Big improvement of the 6.4 motor is fuel efficency. I have a 08 450 w/a 6.4 auto Empty I can squeek 17.5 with 4.30 gears but that is running empty at 55mph. Tune it up past 2000 rpm, and fuel mileage goes in the dumper and power come on like a freight train.

Hauling with the 6.4 is a dream, Mine run 495hp/975 #ft at the rear wheels.

One think of note the new 450 is nothing but a beefed up version of the new F350....

Cheers
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #7  
I honestly wish I could find a high mileage Super Duty with a blown 6.0 for a good price. I've been looking into various truck projects recently and after having stumbled upon "destroked's" website, I must say that I'm intrigued. Apparently it is actually a very easy swap to put a 5.9 Cummins into a 6.0 equipped Super Duty. I think that would make for an awesome combination. If you're worried about the miles on your Super Duty, you may want to look into some sort of update rather than going for the payments on the ridiculously expensive new ones. I just bought a 2010 F250 Diesel 6 months ago and I love my truck. I could have bought a 2011 with the 6.7 powerstroke for a few thousand more, but since I only put about 6,000 miles per year on my trucks and usually trade them inafter 4 or 5 years I would never have saved enough in fuel to justify the extra expense since I got such a terrific deal on my 2010. I almost wish that people would stop buying new trucks in a sort of protest to their outrageous cost. Maybe if people didn't fork out that much money so easily the companies wouldn't charge so much for their trucks in the first place.
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #8  
Although I have a GMC now, I have owned F250's with both the 7.3L and the 6.4L. I was pretty impressed with both, but the 7.3L was pretty highly-modified. My 6.4L was a really good truck. I never had any trouble with the powerplant and it made smooth and ample power. I know the mileage was a concern of many on these engines, but it seemed rear axle ratio played a lot into that. My truck had the 3.73 rear axle and it would handle 11,000+ trailer loads here in the mountains with little trouble, so I suspect for most users it would do fine. I could certainly feel the load, but the truck would move it around safely and quickly. As for mileage, I never was able to do better than 18 unloaded with mine, and this would drop to 10-12 pulling. Interestingly, it would not go below that no matter what the weight of the load. I could get 12 pulling a 2500 pound small trailer/ZTR but would get 10.5 pulling 10K plus. I have never owned a 6.0L, but have too many neighbors and friends with them that have had trouble. The engine is just not well-designed, especially in the head gasket region with a flimsy 10 bolt design and short factory studs. Though many of these were replaced under warranty, my understanding is Ford did not volunteer to repair any that were not giving trouble, which if true, would not sit well with me. The 7.3L is a bulletproof engine, but requires heavy mods to make equal power to the new ones and finding a used one without a ton of miles would be difficult. I have driven a 6.7L and think it is the best of the line to date, but comes only in new trucks with big price tags. My opinion would be the 6.4L in a late model used truck is the way to go here, with the understanding that it is not going to be a fuel sipper, though none of them are right now and unless driving and pulling constantly the cost of operation is likely close to wash.

John M
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #9  
The 7.3L is a bulletproof engine, but requires heavy mods to make equal power to the new ones and finding a used one without a ton of miles would be difficult. I have driven a 6.7L and think it is the best of the line to date, but comes only in new trucks with big price tags. My opinion would be the 6.4L in a late model used truck is the way to go here, with the understanding that it is not going to be a fuel sipper, though none of them are right now and unless driving and pulling constantly the cost of operation is likely close to wash.

John M

I went to a Dodge after owning two of the 7.3 PSD Ford trucks. Those engines leaked like there's no tomorrow, were extremely weak on power and ALWAYS seemed to have some failure that stranded me. They were so bad that they made me a 10 year Dodge owner with the 5.9 Cummins. I just got tired of it and it was getting old. I now have an '06 4X4 F350 with the 6.0 PSD and it's by far the best diesel pickup I've ever owned or driven. I couldn't ask for it do do more than it does. It easily tows 16,000 to 18,000 behind it on long runs no problem. Therefore, I won't be in the market for a new pickup for at least another 6 or 7 years. Then, due to politics, I'll still never consider a new GM. I'll have to see what Ford has compared to Dodge and ??
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #10  
I have done a Cummins to a Ford conversion. Easy??? ys and no. You can fit the engine inthe bay inplace of the 6.0/6.4 without issue but that is to say there will be fabrication involved.

Wiring all to work that is another story do you want all the functionallity in the dash/cab.... a bit of work in invovled there.

I talk to the folks at Destroked about my current ride 08 450 to a Cummins 6.7.... It will take them 4-6 weeks to do the swap and about $10-12K if I supply the engine /trans. Motors are estimated at $5-8 K. Delete all the emissions crap and the engine will last a very long time .
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #11  
MD09 is correct it is not a weekend project installing a 5.9 in a superduty. If you are going to do it youself make sure you do alot of research before you start and the motor should come from a pickup. I just finished one,would I do another one maybe,maybe not.There is alot of work involved to get everything working the way it was before the swap.
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #12  
Dargo, I am familiar with your feelings toward GM and understand them. I also know your service out of the 7.3L engine was not at the level of some others. That said, the party line on the 7.3L is that is was/is a good engine though certainly not at the power level of any of the newer engines without significant mods.

John M
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #13  
There is a very unbiased book called lemon aid. At lease it is here in Canada It reports on problems, thing you should expect as well as all kinds of other advice on vehicles.

They claim the most reliable heavy duty truck is the dodge Cummings with a manual tranny.

It is an interesting read because it does not hold back on what the auto manufactures try to pull off. I believe this book could save you thousands.

Good luck.
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #14  
They claim the most reliable heavy duty truck is the dodge Cummings with a manual tranny.
I agree! :thumbsup: :D
Although, I wouldn't mind one with an Aisin tranny either.
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #15  
Drive a new Ford 6.7 and you will be amazed on a couple of points.
1. The asking price is over the top! but some dealers will work a deal kind of.
2. Performance is unbelivevable out of the box, but you will not find 4.10 gears in the back, or manual transmissions any more....

The 6 speed Auto is pretty tough and from all that I have heard and read it stand up fairly well to 400hp and 800#ft troque. It has 2 OD gears which is kinda cheating to find fuel mileage might not be so great for towing big loads

Big improvement of the 6.4 motor is fuel efficency. I have a 08 450 w/a 6.4 auto Empty I can squeek 17.5 with 4.30 gears but that is running empty at 55mph. Tune it up past 2000 rpm, and fuel mileage goes in the dumper and power come on like a freight train.

Hauling with the 6.4 is a dream, Mine run 495hp/975 #ft at the rear wheels.

One think of note the new 450 is nothing but a beefed up version of the new F350....

Cheers
I just test drove a 2011 f 450, and it had 4:10 gears. In fact all the f 450s I saw at two lots had 4:10 gears. I myself am looking for better fuel mileage, so I don't want 4:10 gears.
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #16  
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #17  
I just test drove a 2011 f 450, and it had 4:10 gears. In fact all the f 450s I saw at two lots had 4:10 gears. I myself am looking for better fuel mileage, so I don't want 4:10 gears.
If you dont need 4.10's, 4.30's, or 4.88's then you do not need a F-450. Get a F-250 with 3.73's.

Like Dmaces said I think 4.30's are the gear in the 450 while the 350 gets 4.10's or 3.73's.

Chris
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #18  
I just test drove a 2011 f 450, and it had 4:10 gears. In fact all the f 450s I saw at two lots had 4:10 gears. I myself am looking for better fuel mileage, so I don't want 4:10 gears.

I had looked at the new (2011) rigs before I bought my 08 450( low mileage one owner) I had a hard time justifying $67K for a truck with an engine made in Mexico (Ford) or $55K for a truck that was built/assembled in Mexico (Dodge).

New Ford 450 uses 17 inch wheels and tires. Load capacity is different than the 2010 units. I too Have seen the 2011 F450 with 4.10 gearing on the MD lots. I think this is to help with fuel mileage and give you some sort of heavy haul capability. I do not believe the 3.73 gearing is available in the 450/550 line as they are advertised as the heavy haulers.

Fuel efficency.... With respect to this issue, it is a real concern and factor with any rig be it a F150 or a W900L Kenworth. You are a fool to not take that into consideration as part of your operational expenses. $200.00 fill ups hurt I do not care who you are.
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #19  
The best thing you can do is go and take a long test drive of any truck you're considering, see if the dealership will let you take it overnight. Either the Ford of the Dodge will be a good reliable truck for you, it just depends which you're more comfortable with and how much you want to pay.
Just for the record i'm a Dodge Ram guy so the Ram gets my vote.
 
/ Superduties?? talk about the recent models #20  
I have a F-350 SRW diesel with 185,000 miles. Only had it for less than two years, but it had high mileage when I bought it. What's the scoop on the newer models? Mine has the infamous 6.0 and I know they have changed engines since. How do the later models compare? I am toying with the idea of trading, but the new sticker price is pretty steep. Are there bargains to be had now? Is Ford dealing on the 2010 or 2011s, or is sticker price standing up. Just curious about the newer ones and what you guys think. I also heard the newer Dodges were nice. (don't want to start a war, just wanted some opinions)

I've owned the following crewcab Ford F350's: 1989, 1995, 2000, 2007 (dually), and 2011 (dually).

The 2011 is by far the best of them. It is heavier duty, has far more power, is quieter, faster, and gets better mileage. The interior is better, the features are better - and yes, you pay for it.

As for the engine being manufactured in Mexico - don't see the problem with that. If they manufactured it in the US that would have just added to the price. People always complain about costs, and when the manufacturer does something to try and contain costs - people complain about that. For the new diesel motor, Ford built an entire new factory in Mexico dedicated to nothing but manufacturing that motor.

John Deere has manufactured diesel engines in Mexico for years. If you have a problem with things manufactured in Mexico, then you probably shouldn't be flying on any airplane with a GE jet engine as most of the commercial GE jet engines are assembled in Monterey, Mexico and have been for years. It has to do with quality control and not where the factory is located.

The new 6-speed automatic is rated for 1100 foot/pounds of torque so the 800 put out by the 6.7 liter won't even come close to taxing it.

The dealers where I live will deal with you. If you can get an X-plan PIN and the documentation to back up the PIN, then you can buy the truck at 0.1% over dealer invoice cost.

Just remember this for any vehicle manufactured by an American auto company. They have "hold back" which is usually 5% of the MSRP sticker on the vehicle. That comes back to the dealer from the manufacturer quarterly, so they can sell you a vehicle at no markup and still make 5% of the MSRP.

One thing you can do, is custom order the vehicle. The custom orders don't show up as part of their inventory and as such won't appear on their floorplan. This gives them more profit as the vehicle doesn't sit on the lot accruing floorplan charges.

Many dealers will give you a better price for ordered vehicles because of this - but, you have to know the game and indicate you understand how it works, as most dealers want to sell the vehicle, but also want as much profit as possible.

Don't pay for dealer "prep" charges which is mostly peeling off the shipping film, washing the vehicle, and inspecting it. Not worth $450 in my book, so I state up front I won't pay for that as that is part of what should be covered by the hold back.

Don't pay excessive document fees. X-plan allows the dealer to charge only $75 for that service and you shouldn't pay anymore than that either.

Shop more than one dealer. Let them know that if you can get the price you want you're ready to buy and not just kicking the tires. I usually try to deal with the commercial / fleet sales people as they're generally the guys who have been at the dealer for years, know more about the products, and aren't the newb sales guys who have to "check with the manager on that" for everything, and don't need a sales manager to OK the sale.

Have never paid more than 1% over dealer invoice for any of the F350's I've purchased. The 2011 had a sticker of $63,900. I had an additional alarm board added to the built-in alarm system (tilt sensor - Ford add-on part 7L3Z19A361 AA - which can be added at the factory as part of a custom order, or added later at the dealer), and a GPS vehicle locating system. The cost - $54.5K with tax, title, licensing.
 

Marketplace Items

832788 (A61166)
832788 (A61166)
500 BBL FRAC TANK (A58214)
500 BBL FRAC TANK...
2018 Ford F-150 4x4 Ext. Cab Pickup Truck (A61568)
2018 Ford F-150...
2013 KENWORTH T800 (A60736)
2013 KENWORTH T800...
2011 Ford F-750 Terex Hi-Ranger 5TC-55 55ft. Insulated Bucket Truck (A60352)
2011 Ford F-750...
2018 CATERPILLAR 336F L (A58214)
2018 CATERPILLAR...
 
Top