RTV vs atv.

[LBrown59]

What's the safety advantages / disadvantages of one over the other one ?.

 

[johnk]

RTV is a 2 seater. Possibly have a dump box on back for moving material. Thats one advantage. Disadvantages are they are less agile in tight spots and not as great for serious trail riding. { Depending on how youm want to ride. Also they are pricier. Atv's are very powerful also and with the right attachments can do some serious work and also trail ride ..

 

[LBrown59]

RTV is a 2 seater. Possibly have a dump box on back for moving material. Thats one advantage. Disadvantages are they are less agile in tight spots and not as great for serious trail riding. { Depending on how youm want to ride. Also they are pricier. Atv's are very powerful also and with the right attachments can do some serious work and also trail ride ..

Which one is safer on rough irrigular hills and side slopes?

 

[Dmace]

Which one is safer on rough irrigular hills and side slopes?

Without a doubt the RTV will be safer since it has seat belts and a full roll cage. Granted it's center of gravity is higher so it's more likely to roll on it's side then an ATV but it's still very stable and safer in a roll.

 

[radioman]

Which one is safer on rough irrigular hills and side slopes?

I say it depends on the driver. With a RTV, You can't exactly lean uphill making a turn and moving the COG to the foot rests with your body weight. With a ATV you can do this in a tighter spot, RTV needs a wider swath of turning but you are safer with roll cage rolling over. Do you feel lucky enough ?

 

[JayC]

Here's a few videos of a tippy RTV900. I wouldn't put too much into them since it was mainly operator error.

YouTube - Kubota RTV 900 rollover

YouTube - Kubota RTV900 on 2 wheels

YouTube - RTV 2 wheels almost flipping over backwards

 

[gumshu]

What's the safety advantages / disadvantages of one over the other one ?.

I would imagine that depends on your needs. Unlike an ATV, I bought my RTV900 for its ability to carry and dump material. While utilizing a bit of caution, it's fine on slopes. It's not a fast machine and it's more top heavy than an ATV, therefore, an ATV would be best for speed and steep trail riding. The RTV is more of a workhorse and a means of transportation rather than a speed and thrill seeking machine. It's got a 23 HP diesel engine which is fine. However, it could use more HP. I think it's a little underpowered going up slopes hauling a heavy load. Otherwise, I've been very satisfied with it.

 

[whistlepig]

What's the safety advantages / disadvantages of one over the other one ?.

Having a cab would make the RTV safer. As far as stability on hills that matters more with the width and center of gravity of the beast rather than if it's a RTV or ATV. A RTV with a bed would be a bit handier for farm chores. An ATV would be easier to maneuver through the woods. I use my ATV for about every farm chore there is that doesn't require an implement. ATV's are fast and just plain fun. I'm an old man but every now I get a bit frisky and wind this puppy out even going airborne at times. Sorry. Just can't help myself.

 

[GreenLawnFarm]

i really want an atv. could also use for trail riding and more fun, but rtv would be more useful. rtv is almost the size of a small pickup truck, hmmmmm and probably the same price.

 

[2DeereSleds]

As stated above, RTV's are generally more geared to transporting people and or loads (i.e. farm use). While this can be done on an ATV's, MOST are designed for ONLY 1 RIDER and you will need a trailer/wagon to carry a lot of equipment/loads.

ATV's are definitely faster and more agile, but there are so many models now with huge engines (gas & diesel), power steering, automatic transmissions, that they are becoming more versatile for both work and play.

The big difference is going to be the $$$.

Something that nobody else mentioned is that an ATV will easily load in the back of a pickup truck, but a lot of RTV's won't, because of their width.

IMHO, determine what you plan to use it for and $$$

2DeereSleds

 

[LBrown59]

As stated above, RTV's are generally more geared to transporting people and or loads (i.e. farm use). While this can be done on an ATV's, MOST are designed for ONLY 1 RIDER and you will need a trailer/wagon to carry a lot of equipment/loads.

ATV's are definitely faster and more agile, but there are so many models now with huge engines (gas & diesel), power steering, automatic transmissions, that they are becoming more versatile for both work and play.

The big difference is going to be the $$$.

Something that nobody else mentioned is that an ATV will easily load in the back of a pickup truck, but
1*a lot of RTV's won't, because of their width.

IMHO, determine what you plan to use it for and $$$

2DeereSleds

1*But don't beeing wider make an rtv harder to roll over than an atv?

 

[whistlepig]

Are RTV's wider than ATV's? I really don't know. We have two ATV's. My wife uses a Honda Rancher and I use a Polaris Sportsman. A Polaris Sportsman is pretty good size ATV. It weighs 770#. The Rancher is a lot easier to move around on because it is lighter (550#) and smaller. When these things get too big, just like tractors, they become unhandy. I can do everything that I can do with my ATV with my 4x4 pickup. But it's much easier for me to move around with the ATV because it is smaller. I can get more work done in a day with an ATV. I think that is why compact tractors are so popular now. Bigger is not always better.

 

[Midsouth]

Not real sure but i would think a rtv would be wider than a atv. I know most rtvs have room for two people to sit side by side.

 

[Sportsman762]

The safety advantages and disavantages are very different for an atv and a RTV because they are two entirely different machines designed for different uses. I use an RTV 900 at work and a Polaris Sportsman 500HO at home. The RTV has Rops and seat belts. The sportsman has neither. You asked which is safer on irregular hills / side slopes. The ATV is much safer. The RTV is wider however its center of gravity is very high also making easier to roll. I would be afraid to take an unloaded RTV up hills hat I would have no qualms about taking my atv up loaded. If you need a UTV that can take hills and carry a load then look at a Polaris Ranger, it might suit your needs better. If you are looking for something sportier than look at a Yamaha Rhino.
Also some notes about RTV performance on hills. They are slow starting off on level ground on hills its a crawl. They supposedly can do 25 mph but we have 4+ at work and they go a little less than 20 mph. They also have a limited slip front end this allows for a single front wheel to spin. Most ATV's eather have a spool up front or a locker. The RTV suspension is to stiff to follow the terrain in difficult areas causing one wheel to leave the ground. Also if you get an RTV stuck you better have a heck of a winch or something large to tow it out because at 1 ton you are not going to be pushing it out.
Sorry for rambling on.

 

[radman1]

I have a side by side kawasaki teryx (750cc) and Kawasaki kodiak 450, a midsized atv. The teryx is faster (50mph), can carry 2 easily and cargo bed. The terxy is the only certified ROPS unit on the market. I rolled the atv once doing a tight turn. I was leaning in but the roll over was kind of slow motion event and I just jumped off on the inside. I don't think the teryx would have rolled over in the same turn. Teryx can do deeper mud but has higher clearance and more aggressive tires. The teryx has a lever to allow the front end to be infinitely variable from limited slip to full lock. Teryx is more controlable at higher speeds. Teryx feels much safer with cage and seat belts. Lots of injuries on side by sides due to operator putting out foot/leg in rollover situation. SNAP goes the leg. Many manufactures now put on doors. I found the doors a PITA if you get on and off a lot. Teryx has no doors but has foot gaurds making it harder to get out. Atv is much better in tight quarters and turning. Big atv may not be much better than the teryx in turns.

On a steep side hill, the atv is probably safer only because the operator can lean up hill. If the operator was upright, the terxy is probably less prone to rollover due to wider stance.

 

[Ken45101]

The answer depends on how you are going to use the unit and what kind of terrain.

We have two ATVs (Honda and Yamaha) and a Kubota RTV-900. We've had the ATVs for 9 and 10 years, the RTV for a year and a half. We have never had any accidents with any of them beyond a cart of firewood rolling over.

HOWEVER, I have friend who has rolled his ATV several times (same model as one of mine). We've been on trails together and I parked mine and walked while he went on down the trail with his. He had trouble getting back up the trail.

If you drive sensibly at reasonable speed and terrain, they can all be safe. BUT I do feel the RTV is safer with the seat belts and roll bar.

 

[whistlepig]

The safety advantages and disavantages are very different for an atv and a RTV because they are two entirely different machines designed for different uses. I use an RTV 900 at work and a Polaris Sportsman 500HO at home. The RTV has Rops and seat belts. The sportsman has neither. You asked which is safer on irregular hills / side slopes. The ATV is much safer. The RTV is wider however its center of gravity is very high also making easier to roll. I would be afraid to take an unloaded RTV up hills hat I would have no qualms about taking my atv up loaded. If you need a UTV that can take hills and carry a load then look at a Polaris Ranger, it might suit your needs better. If you are looking for something sportier than look at a Yamaha Rhino.
Also some notes about RTV performance on hills. They are slow starting off on level ground on hills its a crawl. They supposedly can do 25 mph but we have 4+ at work and they go a little less than 20 mph. They also have a limited slip front end this allows for a single front wheel to spin. Most ATV's eather have a spool up front or a locker. The RTV suspension is to stiff to follow the terrain in difficult areas causing one wheel to leave the ground. Also if you get an RTV stuck you better have a heck of a winch or something large to tow it out because at 1 ton you are not going to be pushing it out.
Sorry for rambling on.

This is a good comparison for me. I have always wondered what the difference would be. I do know that on the side hills that scare me on the tractor or pickup truck are know problem for an ATV. There is one thing bad about ATV's. I used to ride dirt bikes. If I wrecked the dirt bike I could "throw" it away from me. If an ATV flips there is no getting away from it. It's going to be on top of you. And the ATV's these days are pretty heavy.

 

[Rara Avis]

CBS' Rhino Probe Prompts Safety Reminder - CBS News

 

[radman1]

I saw that broadcast. A "CBS exclusive" report ....... The issue has been known for a long time. Vast majority are doing things they should not be doing. I have a Kawasaki Teryx but the Rhino always gets picked on the most. I think they should do an "CBS exclusive report" on the dangers of a motorcyle next. Lots more deaths and injuries compared to a UTV.

 

[plastikosmd]

yea...machines get vilified. sad...I am a 3 wheeler fan...When you really look at the numbers, prior to the ban..you will see that the injury/death rate is no higher than it is today on 4 wheelers...in fact...there are about 30% more injuries today, but that may be related to more machines around...when you read the death reports...and how the machine was 'blamed' it is just plain sad.
many involve alcohol, some..falling off the machine while just sitting on it..not running, one getting electrocuted from running over a live wire...one hit by a train..from the rear..while driving down train tracks..


Remember it is the lawyers that make the money