Spreader Which Spreader

   / Which Spreader #1  

rvtech

Gold Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2005
Messages
297
Location
Sunbury, Ohio, U.S.A.
Tractor
2006 John Deere 2305
I'm interested in purchasing a spreader. I need it only for spreading fertilizer such as "weed and feed" for my lawn. I'll need to go near my house, buildings, and landscaping beds. Typically, I will be spreading over about 2 acres and occassionally 5 acres. I'm not sure if a 3 point funnel type is best or if that's overkill for what I need and a 2 wheel pull behind will work fine.
 
   / Which Spreader #2  
rvtech said:
I'm interested in purchasing a spreader. I need it only for spreading fertilizer such as "weed and feed" for my lawn. I'll need to go near my house, buildings, and landscaping beds. Typically, I will be spreading over about 2 acres and occassionally 5 acres. I'm not sure if a 3 point funnel type is best or if that's overkill for what I need and a 2 wheel pull behind will work fine.

If you plan on spreading much "weed and feed", I'd recommend a drop spreader rather than a broadcast spreader. That same weed and feed you use to kill weeds in your grass will kill your Zinias or whatever other "broadleafs" it lands on/in/around. A drop spreader will only cover what it runs over. Hard to control the coverage with a broadcast spreader in confined areas or near plant beds.

Don't ask me how I know about the Zinias. And do me a HUGE favor, NEVER mention it around my wife. ;)
 
   / Which Spreader #4  


Click on the picture for a larger image. This is the one I purchased,mainly for large amounts of lime. The one smaller was only $20.00 less so, I figured there was not much savings and the smaller one did not have the agitator inside. I bought it at AGRI-SUPPLY.
 
   / Which Spreader
  • Thread Starter
#5  
That looks huge on your machine. I was thinking about a similar spreader, but it sounds like a drop spreader may be better for my use.
 
   / Which Spreader #6  
I'm dealing with the same decision right now. I'm torn between PTO, electric and tow-behind.

Normally, I would probably go with the tow-behind but I'm not sure how it will do on the ice/snow. That is, I will be using it to spread sand/salt on ice/snow and I'm not sure if the wheels will have enough traction. I guess I could always put chains or studs on the tires. Does anyone have any experience in this department?

You may also want to consider an electric spreader commonly seen on ATVs or on 2" receivers behind trucks. They have a smaller capacity similar to many of the tow-behind ground driven units. Since they are not PTO powered, they give you mounting flexibility. That is, you could mount it to the front of your tractor and that would leave your 3PH free for something else.

Many spreaders have an adjustment so you can spread left field, right field or both. Keep in mind that you could easily make a bracket out of plywood or sheet metal to control the flow as well.

Let us know what you go with.
 
   / Which Spreader #7  
rvtech said:
What drop spreader would you recommend?

Sorry for the slow response. I'm at work now, and don't recall the particular model #, but the spreader I use around the yard is a "GANDY" brand drop spreader. It's 4' wide. I tow it with my lawn tractor. (Deere 265) As I recall, they made wider units, maybe 6' or 8'. I've got a "spinner" spreader for fertilizing hayfields and such, but just don't like the lack of control it has in tight quarters. A drop spreader puts down material only where you want it. Again, with weed control (granular 2,4-D?) that makes a big difference around flower beds, gardens, shrubs, and even where you border the neighbors property. Scott, the folks who make all the lawn care products used to market a pull-behind drop spreader. I like smaller sized spreaders for lawn work. There's a number of places in my yard where anything wider than I have just wouldn't fit between beds and the house.
 
   / Which Spreader #8  
ONCE, I used Weed & Feed fert. Killed some veggies I had growing off to the side.

Don't know why I used it, because I found that fertilizer killed my worms in my NJ lawn. After that, I always used composted cow manure. It's a pain to spread though. So, for the last few years I've been using Milorganite.

This year, I switched to Cock A Doodle, chicken-based, fert for my lawn and Espoma 18% N, another organic but cow or pig manure based, to correct the C:N ratio on the sawdust that I get. It would also be good for the lawn.

If you want to find out why fert kills worms, read the book Teaming with Microbes. You can also understand why such low N stuff like Cock A Doodle and Milorganite works, too. They (and compost) feed the microorganisms, which then feed your lawn. Regular fert just nukes everything, and only about 10% of so of it actually gets to the roots of the lawn, e.g. guess where the other 90% goes: ever hear of runoff and sink-in to the water table? With Weed & Feed, you're really nuking everything and weakening the roots of the grass that you really want. Just mow high to let the grass shade out the weeds. Weeds are green, too.

I just spread lime and fertilizer with a hand-held or little 2 wheeled broadcast spreader. I just did my fields with my hand-held this afternoon. Too rough to run the 2 wheely one over and around brush and rocks and stuff. Those big 3 ph ones can put stuff in many places where you don't want it. I'd only use them for doing big open fields.

Ralph
 
   / Which Spreader #9  
Neophyte said:
I'm dealing with the same decision right now. I'm torn between PTO, electric and tow-behind.

Normally, I would probably go with the tow-behind but I'm not sure how it will do on the ice/snow. That is, I will be using it to spread sand/salt on ice/snow and I'm not sure if the wheels will have enough traction. I guess I could always put chains or studs on the tires. Does anyone have any experience in this department?

You may also want to consider an electric spreader commonly seen on ATVs or on 2" receivers behind trucks. They have a smaller capacity similar to many of the tow-behind ground driven units. Since they are not PTO powered, they give you mounting flexibility. That is, you could mount it to the front of your tractor and that would leave your 3PH free for something else.

Many spreaders have an adjustment so you can spread left field, right field or both. Keep in mind that you could easily make a bracket out of plywood or sheet metal to control the flow as well.

Let us know what you go with.


I tried one of Agri-Fab's pull-behind spreaders for spreading a salt/sand mix and it didn't work at all. The material is too heavy for the cotter pin/agitator to turn freely so at the slightest loss of traction the drive wheels just lock up. Tried chains also to no avail. Worked bare3ly better with just an ice melt but not much. Caused more headaches than anything...even for fertilizing/slingin seed I found that it worked marginal at best! And it was the higher-end Agri-fab Agri-Fab Tow-Behind Broadcast Spreader — 250-Lb. Capacity, Model# 45-0364 | Lawn Spreaders | Northern Tool + Equipment

Originally I tried there $50 pull unit and it made one trip around property b4 bending axle. And no I wasnt pullin it with the Vette or tryin to qualify they just suck!! IMHO

Just bought Cosmo 180 from Agri-supply & it looked much smaller on their site. Makes my 2210 look silly but just finished throwin out 200# seed and bout same amount of fertilizer & seemed to work well...would suck in tight/sensitive areas tho. Gonna use for lime next week-end & plan on usin in winter on about 350ft or gravel drive with hopefully improved results. So in answer to yer question save your money.
 
   / Which Spreader #10  
MrGraffix said:
I tried one of Agri-Fab's pull-behind spreaders for spreading a salt/sand mix and it didn't work at all. The material is too heavy for the cotter pin/agitator to turn freely so at the slightest loss of traction the drive wheels just lock up. Tried chains also to no avail. Worked bare3ly better with just an ice melt but not much. Caused more headaches than anything...even for fertilizing/slingin seed I found that it worked marginal at best! And it was the higher-end Agri-fab
I appreciate the feedback. I had a feeling this would be the case. I'm glad you spoke up because I was really leaning towards the pull-behind. I guess now it's a choice between electric and PTO.
 
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2016 PETERBILT PB337 FLATBED TRUCK (A52706)
2016 PETERBILT...
2010 Ford Edge SE SUV (A51694)
2010 Ford Edge SE...
PALLET OF MILITARY STRAPS (A54757)
PALLET OF MILITARY...
PEMBERTON LR129-1123 RAKE ATTACHMENT (A53426)
PEMBERTON...
2005 INTERNATIONAL DURASTAR 4300 (INOPERABLE) (A55745)
2005 INTERNATIONAL...
2003 Big Tex 10PI 16ft. T/A Pipe Top Utility Trailer (A55973)
2003 Big Tex 10PI...
 
Top