I don't have any experience with new VWs, but I'll say this. It's my opinion only, and I'm not trying to present it as fact.
VWs are German cars. Like BMWs and Mercedes, they are a luxury European brand. Yes, I'm sure they're very nice to drive, and yes the diesels get good mileage. They are, however more expensive to purchase and more expensive to maintain than another brand. Personally, I'd pick a Honda or Toyota over VW (or any European brand) every day of the week and twice on Sunday.
If I had a bunch of money laying around, had a thing for German cars, and was gonna trade it in after a couple years, sure I'd buy a VW. Until that day, I'll stick with Hondas and Toyotas. Though I will say that the American sedans have greatly improved in fuel economy and overall longevity, so I'd perhaps consider a new American brand. That'd be less likely, though.