Well, I'm not sure I'm not more confused than I was when I posted the question. /forums/images/graemlins/crazy.gif
The logic of protecting the underside just seems like a good idea to me. The idea that it could chip and hold water seems unlikely given the abuse I've seen this material withstand in truck beds. While the logic of the rougher lining causing more buidup made a bit of sense at first blush, I'd think once the first bit of grass or debris attaches itself to the smooth, unprotected underside, you've got a rough surface anyhow. Some bedliner coatings are 'rubbery' so loads won't shift. I think I'd like just the opposite if it were available.
I'd like to think I wouldn't have to do it, but even if I do this and then use the graphite spray I'd still never have any paint worries underneath. As to the idea that the lining material would wear off, with a lifetime warranty on it, I don't know that I'd be all that concerned.
I found a nationally known vendor today who offered to do a 5' rotary cutter and a 6' finish mower for $100 each. I negotiated a price of $150 for the pair of mowers. /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif For that price they will remove the blades, mask the spindles and topside, sandblast the underside to roughen it for better coating adhesion, apply the coating, remove the masking, clean any overspray, reattach the blades and guarantee the coating for life. I have to say at that money it sounds like a deal to me. /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif
To be fair, the vendor told me he's done this for people before and that some have raved about it while others have been disappointed that they still had to clean the mower underside. I'm not expecting this to cause every bit of dirt and grass to fall off. I'm just of the opinion that I won't have to worry about cleaning it as thoroughly as I might otherwise. Not liking to spend a whole lot of time bent over cleaning things like this, I'm sure leaning toward spending $75 per mower for this and taking my chances that I'll be happy.
I'm still open to the 'con' arguments against this idea, but at this point I'm leaning toward the 'pro' side. I'd still love to hear from someone who's done it.