Skid Steer Stump Grinder What should I get? Anyone???

   / Skid Steer Stump Grinder What should I get? Anyone??? #1  

tuckinlugz

Bronze Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2009
Messages
99
Location
Pensacola Florida Area
Tractor
2006 ASV RC100 & '06 Kubota R520S
Hello,

I looked but could not find a thread on this. I have an ASV RC100 and I am looking to buy a stump grinder. What are you guys using; and does anyone have any reccomendations? I have been looking online for a while and the best I can find is the Quick Attach Brand. Any feed back would be greatly appreciated! Thanks, Mike
 
   / Skid Steer Stump Grinder What should I get? Anyone??? #2  

Attachments

  • stump1.jpg
    stump1.jpg
    29.3 KB · Views: 899
  • stump-grinder.jpg
    stump-grinder.jpg
    105.1 KB · Views: 9,774
  • saw%20closeup.jpg
    saw%20closeup.jpg
    100.3 KB · Views: 1,432
   / Skid Steer Stump Grinder What should I get? Anyone???
  • Thread Starter
#3  
Cool pictures. But I really was wanting to get some direct feed back regarding what people are using, what they like and what they don't like.

Anyone?? Thanks! Mike
 
   / Skid Steer Stump Grinder What should I get? Anyone??? #4  
I have the center unit. With the hyd pressure and GPM that I have, the motor will develop about 22 HP. It grinds OK, but would like more HP, and the carbide teeth are brazed on. You can still sharpen them on the disk.
 
   / Skid Steer Stump Grinder What should I get? Anyone??? #5  
Look up the Miller Stump Grinder and the Fecon stump grinder. They are two of the best for skid steers.
 
   / Skid Steer Stump Grinder What should I get? Anyone??? #6  
i use the Bobcat sgx high flow stump grinder. It's Bobcat's latest model. I like it. though it's a bit bulky, it's actually light and the grinder visibility is excellent plus the housing helps contain chips.

I previously used the CAT XPS stump grinder. It was an '08 model. I liked it's power but it threw chips everywhere and the wheel was smaller thus I couldn't grind as deep.
 
   / Skid Steer Stump Grinder What should I get? Anyone???
  • Thread Starter
#7  
Anyone know any prices on these units? Or does anybody have a good used stump grinder for sale?
 
   / Skid Steer Stump Grinder What should I get? Anyone??? #8  
The bobcat grinder was about $7400 +/-. It's a strong unit like I said but is a bit more complicated than other styles.
 
   / Skid Steer Stump Grinder What should I get? Anyone???
  • Thread Starter
#9  
I got a bobcat SG60 regular flow unit here locally. I am working on getting it to work on my ASV now. See my other threads if you are looking for info on how to do that!
 
   / Skid Steer Stump Grinder What should I get? Anyone??? #10  
The Miller is the best. I worked there throughout college, I have since moved on. If you bought one '06-'10 then I assembled, wired, and plumbed it myself. The other machines are junk for about the same price-meaning those companies either have higher margins or overhead... either way all of the "competition" definitely falls short of the quality and performance of a Miller. Just look at the ones J J posted and compare them to a Miller, LOL! In the pic, the roost isn't even comparable to a chainsaw. Really it's an apples to oranges comparison, the Miller is industrial grade and the others are homeowner models. The stump in the center picture J J posted can be ground to 18" below grade in well under 5 minutes.

2 things:

First: You should know what you are buying.This is a high performance machine, not an auger. It will perform the task with the greatest efficiency and effectiveness, however, it will require maintenance and upkeep on wear items in order to maintain maximum productivity, but when managed correctly this machine is much more profitable than the competition. Plus the engineering and robustness are far superior.

Second: You need horsepower! Fluid power has much more efficiency losses than shaft power (PTO), so you need a lot of horse power to get anything down to the wheel. "GENERALLY" skidsteers can only put about 60% of their engine power to the attachment because of their inefficient gear pumps and other losses along the way. Miller uses an expensive radial piston motor at the wheel which is +90% efficient, maximizing the amount of power to the wheel. So if the unit is mounted on an RC100 you can get at least 50HP to the wheel, which is highly effective. When you get down to about 75 engine HP, the unit is still very effective but not nearly as impressive as when you have a 100HP to play with.

It runs best on an RC 85, 100 or other comparable 80-100HP skidsteer but definitely has to be paired with a skidsteer that has high flow or has the high flow kit: Miller does make an auxiliary high flow kit for the RC 60 that runs an axial piston pump off the crankshaft that enables you to get ~90% of the engine horsepower to the hydraulic motor and then minus about ~8% more there, you can still get 50HP to the wheel. Its about a $5000 kit and you can probably get one made to order for other models but you'd have to call and talk with him about it. There are also models that use a pony motor to run the hydraulic cylinders and save all of the skidsteers power for the wheel. The website doesn't really do justice to the products or advertise all that Miller is capable of. They run about $9500 list price. Don't quote me on any of my rough numbers in this post, just call him if you're interested:

Miller Machine Works 765-659-1524

Stump Cutter Attachments Craft Machine Design
 
Last edited:

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2015 GENIE GS3246 (A45046)
2015 GENIE GS3246...
Large Bucket 84" (A42021)
Large Bucket 84"...
Vivitek DLP Projector (A44391)
Vivitek DLP...
2015 John Deere 4052R Tractor (A44571)
2015 John Deere...
2001 Master Craft AE-5112 (A39160)
2001 Master Craft...
2017 Ford Explorer AWD SUV (A42744)
2017 Ford Explorer...
 
Top