Scag v EXMARK?

   / Scag v EXMARK? #1  

Royboy

Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2006
Messages
45
Anyone have experience with these Zero Turn mowers? I am looking for a smaller (48") mower but it needs to be more rugged than the Gravely Home ZeroTurn ZT2348 that seems to be broken more than usable.

Is Scag or ExMark more durable/reliable?
Is one of them less expensive for similar models?
Any help on making a choice would be helpful!
Thanks!
Roy
 
   / Scag v EXMARK? #2  
I've not owned either one, but both the Scag and ExMark have good reputations and I see a lot of the commercial operators in my area using the Scags.
 
   / Scag v EXMARK? #3  
Anyone have experience with these Zero Turn mowers? I am looking for a smaller (48") mower but it needs to be more rugged than the Gravely Home ZeroTurn ZT2348 that seems to be broken more than usable.

Is Scag or ExMark more durable/reliable?
Is one of them less expensive for similar models?
Any help on making a choice would be helpful!
Thanks!
Roy



Have you bought one yet?
What was it?
 
   / Scag v EXMARK? #4  
I bought a lightly used (120hrs) Scag Freedom Z48 this season. I have mowed 4 times with it so far, and I am thrilled. There are two engine choices, mine has a 26hp Briggs twin. The other choice is a 19hp Kawasaki. The Scag is more robust than the big box/entry level/residential zero turns I looked at. It is not as rugged as the true commercial Scags, but I don't need that, and it isn't priced so high, either.
 
   / Scag v EXMARK? #5  
I bought a new Scag Freedom Z with the 26 Briggs two years ago for my 2.5 acres. Couldn't be happier. I've got 78 hours on it now, and I can cut my yard in an hour and 45 minutes compared to 4 hours on my Craftsman lawn tractor. The Briggs may not hold up for the commercial guys who push their mowers to the limit, but I think it's fine (knock on wood) for a homeowner with several acres. I don't know about the Exmark, but I like the low center of gravity on the Freedom Z.
 
   / Scag v EXMARK? #6  
I have owned a 54" cut Exmark ZTR with a ROPS for 3 years. No problems with it and it is very well built. In my area Exmark is one of the more popular brands. I would get the suspension seat no matter what brand you buy as the ride is better. You may want to look at Ferris ZTR> this is the only one with a shock absorber suspension system which should result in a better ride on rougher lawns. I am surprised the other brands have not incorporated something similar. I paid over 6 K for my mower.
 
   / Scag v EXMARK? #7  
I noticed that the new Simplicity ZTR's have suspension too, but don't have a clue if they are a good mower, or not.
 
   / Scag v EXMARK? #8  
A couple of things that led to my buying the Scag Wildcat was the water cooled Kawasaki engine. I didn't see any other brands with a water cooled engine. It also has an oil cooler, which a few brands also had. I really liked the seat on the Scag. I sat in so many mowers that I don't remember the others seats, but some were also very nice, while others were pretty bad. The Scag has solid front tires. Actually, they are hollow in the middle, but don't hold air and they cannot go flat. The size of the spindles on the Scag, plus the thickness of the steel was more then most other mowers, but I can't say for sure for each brand as my memory isn't positive from one to another. Then the biggest selling point on the Scag over the others, except Kubota, was the dealer. The Scag dealer is there doing this full time. The Exmark dealer is also the Ace Hardware store. I never got a clear answer who does their warrantee work, or what happens if it breaks down on me. For me, it came down to Scag or Kubota. By comparing components and engines, I went for the Scag. Kubota had some issues with their hydraulics, but the mechanic at Kubota told me that Kubota had fixed that problem, then later on he said there never was a problem and it was always the owners using the mowers for towing stuff. He even showed me a zero turn mower with a 2 inch ball mounted to the back of it that he said was the cause of that mowers problems. I can see where a zero turn shouldn't be hauling a trailer, but don't know the other side of it to know for sure if the owner of that particular mower was pulling a plastic garden trailer like so many people do with their mowers, or a much larger trailer. I guess anything is possible, but think the odds are in favor that it was a small garden trailer and that it shouldn't have caused any problems. Since the mechanic at Kubota gave me two different answers while talking to him, I wasn't sure which version to believe.

Eddie
 
   / Scag v EXMARK? #9  
simplicity bought Ferris and now use the suspension system of the FERRIS on their ZTR.
 
   / Scag v EXMARK? #10  
Anyone have experience with these Zero Turn mowers? I am looking for a smaller (48") mower but it needs to be more rugged than the Gravely Home ZeroTurn ZT2348 that seems to be broken more than usable.

Is Scag or ExMark more durable/reliable?
Is one of them less expensive for similar models?
Any help on making a choice would be helpful!
Thanks!
Roy


Sounds like you should have gotten a heavier Gravely. The Home series are on the light side. Now for the disclaimer, I help out at a Gravely, Hustler, Dixon, Toro and Skag dealership. Skags are in the higher price classes that put you in the same lines as the others that are commercial units.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

MACK MP7 ENGINE AND CHASSIS (A45046)
MACK MP7 ENGINE...
2015 Chevrolet Tahoe SUV (A42744)
2015 Chevrolet...
2016 INTERNATIONAL LONESTAR TANDEM AXLE SLEEPER (A43003)
2016 INTERNATIONAL...
JOHN DEERE TRACTOR 5083E (A45046)
JOHN DEERE TRACTOR...
W&A 3pt Ditcher (A44502)
W&A 3pt Ditcher...
1999 Ford Econoline Van, VIN # 1FTRE14W0XHB81450 (A44391)
1999 Ford...
 
Top