Rental Stump Grinder Choices

   / Rental Stump Grinder Choices #1  

Dennisfly

Gold Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2003
Messages
270
Location
Lake Anna, Virginia and Alleghany County, VA
Tractor
John Deere 4410
I have no experience stump grinding but need to rent one to remove about 20 ten to twenty inch stumps. My choices are a Rayco RG27 which is 27 horsepower and about 1800 lbs. or a Vermeer SC362 which is 35 horsepower and about 1300 lbs. Both are about the same price and distance. The cutting wheels and hydraulic controls appear to be comparable. Any experienced opinions on which one I should use?
 
   / Rental Stump Grinder Choices #2  
I had a Big Vermeer 665A I think. I bought it because it had a wired remote. This is highly usefull. Now I only have a little Steiner one, But better than nothing I guess.

Is access an issue? My vermeer was towed which limited it's access.
 
   / Rental Stump Grinder Choices #3  
I have no experience stump grinding ...

That begs the question, do you REALLY want to take on a fairly large project? I had/have about 50 in the 6" diameter range and considered renting a small two wheeled unit, but wasn't sure I'd be able to do them all in one day. At the rental rate, 2-3 days wasn't really an option for me. I ended up cutting most of them off at or just below ground level with a reciprocating saw so I could mow over them. That was fine for my small ones, but wouldn't work for your larger ones. With my small backhoe now, I've been able to dig out several more including a few larger ones. But I can take my time, learning as I go without worrying about incurring another day's rental rate.

Have you priced having a contractor come in and do it?
 
   / Rental Stump Grinder Choices #4  
Those small hand moved/operated rental units will beat you to death. I did that for two 3' across stumps and "never again!" If you are renting something get one the 4 wheelers that are hydraulically operated. Expensive but worth it for a big job.

Ron
 
   / Rental Stump Grinder Choices
  • Thread Starter
#5  
Those small hand moved/operated rental units will beat you to death. I did that for two 3' across stumps and "never again!" If you are renting something get one the 4 wheelers that are hydraulically operated. Expensive but worth it for a big job.

Ron

I tried to rent the Vermeer but it was not available. So, I ended up with the Rayco which was a good machine. I put 6.7 of the allowable 8 hours on the meter in the 24 hour period I had rented it. I also had to allow for one hour transport each way, cleaning, loading. and darkness, I rented it overnight so I could rest overnight between grinding periods. It's not particularly hard work, but you do need to pay attention. I have a chainsaw logger's helmet with ear muffs and face screen which is good, because it does throw some chips your way on occasion. The work station is to the side so you can see what you are doing, which is good, but you have to keep your head turned to the side which gets old after a while.

This is a four wheel machine with hydraulic motion, steering, and cutter left, right, up, and down. It worked well, but it still took some time to do a large stump. I managed to do ten stumps which were the ones closest to the house and the largest. So, I got the most important ones. The local "for hires" here would just charge for the machine rental and add an hourly fee so I didn't go that route.

Depending on my motivation, I might rent one again (maybe Vermeer this time) and do the remaining less important stumps.

Just FYI, the machines were available from two different rental companies. The Jayco was $250 per day and the Vermeer is $265.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2014 FORD F-150 (A45046)
2014 FORD F-150...
2020 RAYCO 1800AWL Articulated Wheel Loader (A44571)
2020 RAYCO 1800AWL...
8-Seater Electric Golf Cart (A44572)
8-Seater Electric...
Perkins Power Unit (A44502)
Perkins Power Unit...
2012 Ford F-350 XL (A44501)
2012 Ford F-350 XL...
2018 Ford F-550 Truck, VIN # 1FDUF5GTXJEC35552 (A44391)
2018 Ford F-550...
 
Top