Need Opinion, which is the better tractor?

   / Need Opinion, which is the better tractor? #1  

RancherSam

Silver Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2005
Messages
102
Location
Hays County, TX
Tractor
Case IH JX95 4x4
I'm looking at purchasing a tractor that will be used mostly for farmwork (cutting / bailing hay ), some loader work, and some implement work like some auger work.

The tractors I'm looking at:
Case JX75
NH TN75-A
Kubota 6800
MF 471.

Any clear winner there in your opinion? and why?
 
   / Need Opinion, which is the better tractor? #2  
Sam,

We bought a M6800 about a month or so ago. For us, the Kubota was the clear winner because of our past experiences with the dealership and our previous Kubota tractors. Because this is Deere country, we really looked hard at John Deere. But the dealer wasn't willing to work with us. We weren't spending enough money to make it worth his time to talk to us.

We’ve owned two Kubotas and a Harry Ferguson previous to purchasing this tractor and have been pleased with the durability and performance of our prior tractors. I’ve also done a lot of work at the hay farm next door and all they run are Deeres. Their tractors have also been trouble free.

The M6800 has been a great tractor. It has a quiet and smooth running engine. When it starts cutting really thick grass, you can hear the motor kind of ‘grunt’ through it. For me, the seat is very comfortable and the steering is precise. The front end loader joystick falls right into my hand, and the two remote levers are at my fingertips. I spent about 14 hours on the tractor this weekend and am none the worse for wear.

Hooking up implements isn’t too bad. The telescopic lower links really helps getting things lined up.

For me, Kubota won because of the following:

Dealer – the dealer was, hands down, the best I’ve dealt with (he also carries the NH and Mahindra brand)
Price – good price on the tractor
Features – the tractor had all the features we wanted
Prior Experience – all of our previous Kubotas have been bullet proof

Personally, I don't have any blind faith in any one brand of anything. I want the best possible machine for the best possible price with the best possible dealer support. For me, when I was ready to buy, it was Kubota. It could just as easily been John Deere, NH, IH, or any other brand.

My dealer asked what I needed my tractor to do and then what I wanted it to do. He inquired about future work and implements as well as current equipment. Then we went out and looked at all the tractors he thought would suit the job (this included the NH and Mahindra). After playing with his tractors, we started talking about the price. We compared the cost of the Kubota to the others, and it came out the winner.

The John Deere dealer acted like he was doing us a favor by stepping out of his air conditioned office to show us his eqiupment.

Find the tractor that suits you best, the dealer you most want to work with, and then settle on the price. Any of the machines you listed are a fine choice.
 
   / Need Opinion, which is the better tractor? #3  
They are all clear winners if you have a good dealer. I am a Kubota man, but I could drive many other tractors if the dealer was near. Which dealer will take care of you the way you choose. I do not require a great deal of dealer support others may need more. What do you need? Post pictures of your choice!
 
   / Need Opinion, which is the better tractor? #4  
have you driven all the tractors you mentioned? some times one will just fit you better, seat, controls etc.
 
   / Need Opinion, which is the better tractor? #5  
<font color="blue"> The tractors I'm looking at:
Case JX75
NH TN75-A
Kubota 6800
MF 471.
</font>

Have you received prices on the 4 tractors?

RedDog
 
   / Need Opinion, which is the better tractor? #6  
I ended up purchasing a TN75A after looking at many of the same models you have listed. I narrowed my purchase down to the TN75 or JD 5420 -

The TN had a few more HP and was about $3K less than the JD. I also liked the fit and feel of the TN better. Having no levers on the platform between my legs was also a plus, and the main reason I did not buy the Kubota.

Try 'em all out several times before you make your decision. I don't think you will go wrong with any of your choices.

Good Luck and have fun
 
   / Need Opinion, which is the better tractor? #7  
<font color="blue">Having no levers on the platform between my legs was also a plus, and the main reason I did not buy the Kubota.
</font>


I agree! /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif

Levers and such are much better placed at your sides.

RedDog
 
   / Need Opinion, which is the better tractor? #8  
Re: Need Opinion, which is the better tractor? *DELETED*

Post deleted by Bird
 
   / Need Opinion, which is the better tractor? #9  
I just agreed to buy a TN70 mainly because of local dealer. I have looked over JD 5320, 5325, 5420, 5425, MF 461, MF471, and a Kioti DK65. The Kioti was not local dealer and it was an out of state dealer so they had two strikes. Nothing at all wrong with the tractor itself. I like the bigger flow pump that was on the TN70. The JD's compared but a lease unit was months away and also the price really was not all that good for one with 500hrs (25k). The new JD's were from 28 to 34k depending on the model and options. The MF's were 28 to 30k but seem to have the "old" style options still on the tractor. Gears between your legs, longer wheel base, metal all over, and for the price the NH was a better fit for me. The NH was priced at 28700 wFEL, hay spear, and canopy, 1 remote, large pump. I ended up getting it for 30400 with 6' heavy duty brown mower. The decision was really dealer support then price. Both the JD and NH dealers were local. The MF and Kubota dealers were not local they were about 100 miles away not bad but not great either.

Just my story.
 
   / Need Opinion, which is the better tractor?
  • Thread Starter
#10  
Thank you all for very helpful reviews. Many times I've read that dealer support is what seals the deal. Can you elaborate on this? What would you consider good dealer support?
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

JOHN DEERE 5115M TRACTOR (A51243)
JOHN DEERE 5115M...
LIKE NEW 2023 Rhino 84in Reverse Rotation Rotary Tiller (A52748)
LIKE NEW 2023...
2010 Ford Edge SE SUV (A51694)
2010 Ford Edge SE...
2017 E-Z Beever M12R Towable Brush Chipper (A50322)
2017 E-Z Beever...
378803 (A51573)
378803 (A51573)
2010 Ford Edge SE SUV (A51694)
2010 Ford Edge SE...
 
Top