Massey 1742, 1736, or JD 3039r

   / Massey 1742, 1736, or JD 3039r #1  

hunterj

Member
Joined
Jun 27, 2016
Messages
25
Location
south carolina
Tractor
2010 cub cadet
Will be used for landscaping, plowing garden spots, bush hogging and general property maintenance. Most equipment we have is 5ft and 6ft in size. Currently running a 1980 massey 240. Looking to add a 4x4 with loader in one of these tractors. Any help in deciding would be appreciated. Dealers are both about same distance from us just different directions.
 
   / Massey 1742, 1736, or JD 3039r #3  
Don't know the Massey's. Just learning my new 3039r enjoying it a lot
 
Last edited:
   / Massey 1742, 1736, or JD 3039r
  • Thread Starter
#4  
I went with the massey 1742. Few reasons, heavier tractor, front implement diversity with the skidsteer style, lower pricing. Sure the Deere would have worked just as well. 3000 was a big difference.
 
   / Massey 1742, 1736, or JD 3039r #5  
Congrats! Show action pics when u get her home
 
   / Massey 1742, 1736, or JD 3039r #6  
Pretty sure you can get most if not all JDs with a SSQA these days. Especially the non-economy (E) models.
 
   / Massey 1742, 1736, or JD 3039r
  • Thread Starter
#7  
Heading out on vacation. Pick it Friday or Saturday when I return
 
   / Massey 1742, 1736, or JD 3039r #8  
I've had a Massey 1736 (cab) for a couple of weeks now. So far I really like it. The only issue I see so far is that the fuel gauge is a little flaky, that and it is a bit thirsty it seems, but I did have a Belarus 220 which basically "sipped" fuel. The Massey id probably using 1.5 to 1.75 gallons of fuel per hour if I had to guess, so not terrible...I think I'm just used to my old one.

LM
 
   / Massey 1742, 1736, or JD 3039r #9  
I've had a Massey 1736 (cab) for a couple of weeks now. So far I really like it. The only issue I see so far is that the fuel gauge is a little flaky, that and it is a bit thirsty it seems, but I did have a Belarus 220 which basically "sipped" fuel. The Massey id probably using 1.5 to 1.75 gallons of fuel per hour if I had to guess, so not terrible...I think I'm just used to my old one.

LM

"Thirsty". Have you checked how many gallons go in when it's showing empty. Mine takes just around 5 gallons and it's a 10 gallon tank, go figure. Whether they just read wrong or it's idiot proof to an extreme degree who knows. I run mine with a 5' bush hog and can mow 10 acres and do that with well under a tank of gas. It's possible too that you are sailing through it because you are breaking in a new engine and are running it hard. I hope for they changed the manual on break in or you are ignoring it. The idiots in the 2014 owners manual tells you to run the first 50 hours at "full power". Now that will suck down the fuel. The dealer thought that was idiotic as well and just said to run it hard and not lug it.
One other thing that throws the fuel off is the single filler cross over tank arrangement. You fill the thing fast and take off only to see the gauge dropping fast because the tank never was full . Half of whatever you put in has drained across over to the other side giving you the impression you are burning lots of fuel.
Give it a while, you will get used to it. One thing to watch on that machine is the hydraulic hoses. They must be running right near their rating . I had one start leaking within 10 hours and am now on hose # 3 at 260 hours. Every one just started leaking an inch or 2 up from the connection with no damage at all. The last one I got was from a John Deere dealership and it's about 1/4 thicker in diameter than the rest and rated for 4700 PSI.
 
   / Massey 1742, 1736, or JD 3039r #10  
Thanks for the insight Drizler, I'll keep an eye on those hoses. Yes, the fuel gauge is a bit flaky on these things as I see the same thing and sometimes nothing at all even when there is 1/2 to 3/4 of a tank in the machine. I think I'm right at 1.5 gallons per hour, as I've put about 20 hours on it and 30 gallons of fuel in it. As far as break in, I've been running a 72" finish mower on it over 6 acres high mowing a new alfalfa crop (cutting the weeds down), and running a 48" brush mower on about 5 acres of land that sat without crop for 3 years (heavier grass and weeds that would choke the finish mower). Of course, the mowers need to be run at full power, but they really don't lug down this tractor at all, maybe a handful of times has the PTO tach dropped below 540 rpm. Other than that, I ran my 55 inch Agric tiller on it last Sunday and tilled about 1/2 acre for a food plot and it had NO PROBLEM with that tiller. I'm sure this tractor can run a larger tiller, but I think I'll stay with this one for now as it works well and can be offset to one side if need be. I'm going to have it back to the dealer here in a week or 2 to have the fuel gauge looked at and the tires filled. The dealer recommends just the rear tires, although my brother has a Kubota (2650) and his dealer recommend filling all 4 tires. I guess they fill them with beet juice around here because it's heavy, doesn't freeze solid and is non-corrosive.

So I've only had it 2 weeks or so and ran it for 20 hours, but it appears to be a good solid tractor. I added a nice stereo to the cab which was pre-wired for it with speakers. The speakers sound real good, and I had to add an antenna. I used a marine coil type antenna so I didn't need to add an aerial antenna external to the cab. I'm not sure who makes the cab but it appears to be of good quality and has quite a bit of German writing on it. I have an employee who worked for a cab manufacture here in MN and he said the German made cabs are very nice and good quality. So far that appears to be true. I have another brother that has a John Deere 4520 (so with the Kubota, the JD and now my Massey we have the brands covered). Anyway, I have spent considerable time in the JD 4520 and right off the bat, the Massey cab has that particular cab beat hands down. The JD 3039r looks to have a similar cab to the JD 4520 so in a cab comparison this info would be relevant. What I like better on the Massey cab over the Deere is the fact that ALL doors and windows have gas assist cylinders on them. The 4520 only has one on the left hand door which is annoying when you want to use the right hand door. The Massey also has 2 more windows, not sure if that's good or bad at this point, but it does. Also comparing a very similar type of running gear between the JD 4520 and the Massey (both 3 range HST's) the Massey shifts between ranges much more easily. The Deere always seems to be a hassle to shift between ranges, and it hasn't changed or loosened up since it was new and now has a few hundred hours on it. I don't have a lot of comparison between the Kubota, mainly because I have never operated it. Like the JD, the Kubota is a very nice tractor and I think they all will and are going to have their pro's and con's, just hopefully the con's aren't show stoppers.

LM
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

Hyster H225E (A47384)
Hyster H225E (A47384)
14ft Bi-Parting Iron Gate (Cow Design) (A51573)
14ft Bi-Parting...
New Long Forks (A53002)
New Long Forks...
2016 Ford F-450 Cab and Chassis Truck (A51692)
2016 Ford F-450...
Kubota Salt-Spreader (A52384)
Kubota...
1995 VOLVO BM A25C 6X6 OFF ROAD WATER TRUCK (A51246)
1995 VOLVO BM A25C...
 
Top