Kubota B1750D Geared Transmission whines when driving or pto is engaged

   / Kubota B1750D Geared Transmission whines when driving or pto is engaged #1  

Gambler2377

New member
Joined
Oct 16, 2013
Messages
3
Location
Columbus, OH
Tractor
Jinma 284, Kubota L2600, Ford 8N, Kubota B1750
I just bought a Kubota B1750D 6 speed geared transmission with 1260+ hours off a guy who buys/sells tractors, mowers, etc. The engine seems to purr with hardly any smoke and very little blow-by that I could feel. The clutch grabs a little faster than my L2600, but didn’t seem horrible. Here is the issue. If I put the tractor in any gear hi or low range, 2wd or 4wd, and drive it, it will whine with a sound very similar to what a hydrostat sounds like when operating. It makes the noise on level ground and it sounds louder going uphill. The noise decreases drastically or even subsides when going downhill. If it is sitting still in neutral there is no noise or will immediately stop if in gear and the clutch gets disengaged (pedal pushed). If it’s in neutral and the pto is engaged the whine will start again, but it may not be as bad as when in gear. Higher rpm’s seem to make the whine louder.
I changed the trans fluid (used Cam2 which is supposed to be equivalent to UDT) and cleaned the strainer. There was a small amount of metal particles, but the strainer had a thin mud-like layer on it. The air filter on it was filthy so I just figured the tractor had been run in real dusty conditions without good maintenance. At any rate, that had no affect on the whine and I didn’t really expect it to.
The only work I’ve done with it, is climbing a very sizable hill with a 42” bush hog on back and then taking down shoulder high weeds in a field for over an hour in low range 3rd gear 4wd. It whined the whole time but didn’t affect operation. I stopped at the local (30 minutes away) Kubota dealer and a service guy came out and drove it. He thought the sound resembled a turbo, which obviously it does not have. He climbed all around it while having me depress the clutch to kill the whine. He said he couldn’t pinpoint it, but figured it was probably a transmission bearing as opposed to the clutch. He suggested that if I could live with the noise I should use the tractor until it breaks. His thoughts were that it may not be worth the money of cracking the tractor to try and find and fix it as it may run as is for years. I told him that I’ll probably run the tractor 25-50 hours a year. I do smell a little clutch burn as I use it, but I catch that on L2600 occasionally, too.
Long post, but I wasn’t sure what to do. What are your guy’s thoughts?
 
   / Kubota B1750D Geared Transmission whines when driving or pto is engaged #2  
I don't know, but have wondered about noisy tractor transmissions whether they use straight spur gears rather than gears with helical teeth. Straight gears whine. Older cars used to do this, but newer ones have helical gears that are much quieter. Your comments about going downhill make sense, because the whine increases with loading.

So, are you saying that you've heard many geared tractors, and your particular machine is much noisier than they are? Or are you interpreting this one tractor by itself? I see your profile lists a few tractors, does that mean you are comparing this machine to numerous others?
 
   / Kubota B1750D Geared Transmission whines when driving or pto is engaged
  • Thread Starter
#3  
I’m comparing it to my L2600DT, Ford 8N, Jinma 284, and other geared tractors I’ve driven. When I say it makes a noise similar to a hydrostat, I’m really close on the description.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2014 International DuraStar 4300 Terex BT3063 30,000LB Crane Truck (A48081)
2014 International...
2018  FREIGHTLINER M2 26FT NON CDL BOX TRUCK (A52576)
2018 FREIGHTLINER...
2010 Ford Edge SE SUV (A51694)
2010 Ford Edge SE...
2013 Road King 30ft T/A Boat Trailer (A51694)
2013 Road King...
2018 CATERPILLAR TL1055D TELESCOPIC FORKLIFT (A52705)
2018 CATERPILLAR...
Pull-Behind Smooth Drum Ballast Roller (A52377)
Pull-Behind Smooth...
 
Top