King Kutter / New Holland Showdown

   / King Kutter / New Holland Showdown #1  

HRS

Gold Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2005
Messages
397
Location
Georgia
Well, this weekend we had them both in the field: I with my NH, and my brother with his KK. The obstacles included four food plots. Two were of 1/2 acre in size and the other two were each ¼ acre. One of the smaller plots was virgin ground. One of the larger had not been cut in over a year, while the last two had been tilled this past spring. The NH tiller was powered by a TC30 and the KK was driven by a TC33.

Arriving at the property first, I had the TC 30 churning up the plot that had not been cut in over a year. Having read a good deal about the importance of building the organic content of soil, I decided that each plot would be tilled no deeper than 4 inches. So I set my tiller, put the tractor in 1st gear, medium, and let her eat. Within a little while, I had the plot tilled and then jumped on one of the smaller plots. After completing this one too, my brother pulled up with his TC33. We set the KK, and let her spin on the third plot.

Hmmm… I couldn't help but admire the cut the KK was making. I thought it looked a little smoother than mine. But that might have been due to the gates. His was lowered and mulching, while mine was raise and kicking it out. No matter. Either was a vast improvement over any harrow. The grass roots did not stand a chance. All had sprayed about a month earlier and the tillers were tearing them up.

On to the virgin soil… This piece had been sprayed, yet never even mowed. Most all of the grass had browned and matted down, so I dropped on it first and started walking over it with ease. Soon I heard my engine bog, so I decided that medium was too high. Dropping to 3rd gear low answered this problem. The tractor still moved at a decent pace yet it no longer bogged at any point. After a few passes, the TC 33 was tilling in the same bed. Shortly there after, my brother signaled for me to drop it to 3rd low. I smiled and nodded.

Here the ground was not giving up anything without a fight. The till pattern looked about the same (since I had adjusted my setting), yet I still admired that KK. It just looked beefy, and it was doing a fine job.

Up at the head of this little plot, I circled back with the 33 right on my heels, and this is when disaster struck. Mowing over a sprig of a bush, its thigh-size root became logged in the tiller. Apparently, its root had grown to some size over the years even though rotary cutters had often dispatched of the top growth. The NH tiller and 30 did a fine job of snatching this "stump" right out of the ground. Unfortunately, it made a few rounds before I hit the clutch. This jarring motion actually snatched the gates chain in half. I had to dismount and pry the wedge loose and reset the chain to another link. All while that KK tilled right on past me.

So in short, I guess the KK won. I was sent to the pit for repairs while it continued to work. But the job was all but complete by then anyhow. And what fun it was to knock out the work with the little New Holland's.
 
   / King Kutter / New Holland Showdown #2  
Nice! I can't comment on the NH tiller, but the KK has been faithful for the past 4 years. It's lived on a steady diet of old stumps, rocks from silver dollar size to just plain hugh. Takes a lick'n and keeps on till'n!

jb
 
   / King Kutter / New Holland Showdown #3  
Good report. I have a TC and a 5 foot KingKutter tiller. Like my outfit, in fact I tilled a fall garden tonight for one of my neighbors.
 
   / King Kutter / New Holland Showdown
  • Thread Starter
#4  
I tell ya, this was the second season for the NH tiller. My brother has owned his KK for several years but never really tried it out. Some time before I bought my tractor, we would use his on the plots, and he would always bring over a medium set of harrows to break the ground. They did OK in the spring, little green growth to fight. However, it was an absolute joke in the fall. The harrow had too little weight to do anything. It just rode up on top of the carpet the grass roots had created over the summer. I tried to get him to bring out the tiller, but he just didn't think it would do anything.

But after I got one and he saw the results from this spring, I didn't even have to ask him to come out when he heard I was going to cut up the ground last week. He showed up and was pleasantly surprised at how quickly the tiller was able to be pulled over the ground. He had it in mind that they had to be used in creeper gear, like 1st low. Nothing wrong with that, but if I can find a higher gear that the engine will not bog in, then that is what its pulling in.

The King Kutter is a nice tiller. Very heavily built. And not the least of which, it's made by boys in Alabama, if I remember correctly. I'm still interested in a finishing mower myself. Been using the rotary cutter this summer, but I would not hesitate to purchase the KK mower and keep the extra cash. If their tiller is that good, their mowers must be also.
 
   / King Kutter / New Holland Showdown #5  
King Kutter makes a few items that I'm a bit skeptical about. OK for occasional use, but not quite "industrial" enough for hard pounding usage. That said, their tillers are second to none. And for the buck, they're a tough act to follow. I bought a slightly used 72" KK tiller at auction almost 5 years ago. It's been used far more than average since. I even used it to work up a 27 acre cornfield to get it ready for seeding to a hayfield 3 summers back. One pass set at 2-1/2" deep and done. I've worn the tines to what I'd consider the 1/2way point. Still no problems. From this point on, all it will do is work our 2 garden plots. No more big chores. (2 garden spots amount to maybe 3/4 acre)

Considering my negative views of most King Kutter equipment, it was an epiphany of sorts to see their tiller perform as well as it has. Maybe I've just overlooked KK without just cause.
 
   / King Kutter / New Holland Showdown #6  
HRS said:
And not the least of which, it's made by boys in Alabama, if I remember correctly.

I'm 99% certain that the tillers are made in KK's Ohio plant. I know they're not made in the Winfield, AL plant. The plant in Winfield, AL makes most all of the other implements (kutters, finish mowers, disks, box blades, rear blades, cultivators, landscape rakes, etc.).

Later,

BR
 
   / King Kutter / New Holland Showdown #7  
How big are your tillers, HRS? 5 footers? Many rocks in your soil?
Bob
 
   / King Kutter / New Holland Showdown
  • Thread Starter
#8  
Yes, the tillers are both 5 ft. Both tractors handle them just fine. Not many rocks, in the field we foodplot. Got a few in my home garden. I have also used tiller there. Stones are sometimes double fist to smaller. Not all that many either. You can hear when one is thrown out. If you have bunches of stones, well... Maybe someone else could tell you how a tiller stands up to them.
 
   / King Kutter / New Holland Showdown #9  
I tilled 3 plots today with a borrowed 5' KK2 tiller. Well used but effective. I set the cruise at .7 MPH on the JD 3520 and never knew it was back there. All virgin ground. It was my first time tilling and I enjoyed it. I just hope the seed comes up. Need rain.
 
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2020 KUBOTA RTV X1100C UTV (A51406)
2020 KUBOTA RTV...
UNUSED FUTURE CG34 - 34" HYD CLAMP GRABBER (A51248)
UNUSED FUTURE CG34...
2019 JGL 2632ES 26ft Electric Scissor Lift (A50322)
2019 JGL 2632ES...
1638 (A51247)
1638 (A51247)
JOHN DEERE 54D LOT IDENTIFIER 147 (A53084)
JOHN DEERE 54D LOT...
ATLAS XAS110 COMPRESSOR (A52472)
ATLAS XAS110...
 
Top