I need vise advise.......

   / I need vise advise....... #1  

MotorSeven

Elite Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2005
Messages
4,176
Location
NE TENN (Hancock Co)
Tractor
Kioti DK40SE Hydro
Ok, i know this seems trivial, but i saw a Harbor Freight 6" vice on sale the other day for 39 bucks. I didn't buy it because i want a vise that won't explode the first time i lock something in it and start pounding on it with a maul. Anyway....who make a quality vise?

RD
 
   / I need vise advise....... #2  
If you want a vise that will last for a lifetime buy a Wilton. I own nothing but Wilton vises and will buy nothing else. Like most thing's in life you get what you pay for.
 
   / I need vise advise....... #3  
I will second the thought on the Wilton vise. They are expensive, but they are not indestructible. Most times a vise is destroyed not by use, but by abuse. I had a great vise that was over 30 years old that was in perfect working condition. When I moved, I let a friend take my work bench and vise to "store" it for me until I relocated to a place that I could put it. In less than a year, they totally trashed that vise to the point that it wasn't usable. I should have known better since every vise in the shop was barely usable. They would hammer on the handle to get it tighter, and if that didn't work, they would use a pipe on the handle till they got it so tight that the handle would bend. I never could understand why they thought that it had to be that tight, and I believe that the true reason was that the vises were not large enough to handle the work that they tried to hold in them. This is an important lesson. Make sure that the vise that you buy is the size that you will need. If the vise isn't large enough to hold what you put into it, you will keep trying to make it tighter to hold the work. Also, a vise is primarly for holding, not hammering on. Some vises do have anvils on the rear of them, but if you need to hammer on the item, you should also have a anvil in your workshop. Anvils are for hammering, vises are for holding. Be prepared to spend a lot of money on a quality vise, but you will only buy it once. Dusty
 
   / I need vise advise....... #4  
Well, I have an el cheapo vise.

I looked at the Wiltons, but the cost was very high. That was 20 years ago, they are probably more today.

I am one of those guys who doesn't use a vise very often, and I figured I could buy a cheap one and replace as necessary.

As with anything in life, there is pleasure from a well-made tool, but if I need to hammer something in the vise, I can just go ahead & do it without worry.

Haven't had to replace it in 20 years either...
 
   / I need vise advise....... #5  
a junk quality product of 20 years ago is today premium quality product.
 
   / I need vise advise....... #7  
Mornin RD,
I will third the Wilton ! :) This is the vise that I have on my bench at work and use it quite often ! Although I did take the serrated jaws out and made new smooth face jaws for the type of work that I generally do.

At home no Wilton :( Two woodworking vises and one cheapo :confused:
 
   / I need vise advise....... #8  
MotorSeven said:
Ok, i know this seems trivial, but i saw a Harbor Freight 6" vice on sale the other day for 39 bucks. I didn't buy it because i want a vise that won't explode the first time i lock something in it and start pounding on it with a maul. Anyway....who make a quality vise?

RD

Dad had a BIG Wilton vice as long as I can remember. I thought I'd buy one too. Bought #1 and promptly broke the jaws. (doing sickle bar sections) #2 was around maybe 5 years and I broke that one too. (Don't remember exactly how) After dad passed away, I got his OLD Wilton. 15 years later, it's still solid as a rock.

They don't make 'em like they used to. They never did.
 
   / I need vise advise....... #9  
I killed one cheap chinese vice - and got the biggest one from HD I could find. The one with pipe jaws on the bottom. It is chinese too, but so far it holds fine. It was $50 or so - and I would buy it again.
 
   / I need vise advise....... #10  
I go with the HF el cheapo. I weld , build trailers repair tractors ect. and use a vise a lot. The main thing to remember is anything can be torn up. My dad used to say you can destroy an anvil if you beat long enough.
The HF vise is not the greatest quality, but if used as intended:IE: for a vise, not a press, not an anvil, mine has preformed well. I put something in the vise to hold, I don't use a hammer to tighten it, if it needs that much pressure you need a press not a vise and if something is in the jaws I don't hammer on it in there. I've had mine for a while and it has been used a lot, but hasn't been abused. A Wilton can be torn up if abused and so can a HF Chinese vise. Later,Nat
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2025 Auger Skid Steer Attachment (A53421)
2025 Auger Skid...
2006 Magnolia Dry Fertilizer Tender Trailer - Dual Stainless Compartments, Hydraulic Doors (A55301)
2006 Magnolia Dry...
2010 Ford F-750 Stellar 10621 10,000LB 5 Ton Crane Mechanics Truck (A51692)
2010 Ford F-750...
1995 Ford L8000 Grain Truck GARAGE KEPT (A55301)
1995 Ford L8000...
2018 Toro Workman GTX Electric Utility Cart (A54811)
2018 Toro Workman...
Set 4- 10-16.5 tires/wheel for bobcat (A53421)
Set 4- 10-16.5...
 
Top