Hydraulic Post Driver Recommendations

   / Hydraulic Post Driver Recommendations #1  

SteveBenson

Silver Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2001
Messages
181
Location
Eastern Connecticut
Tractor
TC40D
I have about 400 posts to put in this spring and was looking for advice on which post driver would be best for me. I have a NH TC40D (40HP) with one hydraulic pair. Primarily, I will be driving 4x4 posts for horse fencing. I usually try to keep my top rail at about 54”, so a driver that can handle 9’ posts would be fine for the most part. I would like to have the ability to drive 10’ posts, but I would rather go with a 9’ driver if it is better matched to the size of my tractor. I have looked on the worksaver web site at the model 16 with the hydraulic tilt and stabilizer legs. Looks like a good candidate, but I’m still not clear on what models my tractor would handle well. I have 8-12” of heavy clay soil, on top of hardpan in some areas, with some (but not too bad) fieldstone 8-12”. Any suggestions?
 
   / Hydraulic Post Driver Recommendations #2  
I have a Danuser MD6 pto driver. All of the Danuser equipment that I have saw have been notch. They are built for years of commercial use. I would sure buy a Danuser again. They did have one pto model and two hydraulic models, but I didn't see the hydraulic ones on their new updated site. You might e-mail them to check what is available and the usable post size. They will answer e-mail promptly.
 
   / Hydraulic Post Driver Recommendations
  • Thread Starter
#3  
What are the pros and cons of the PTO vs. hydraulic model? Anyone?
 
   / Hydraulic Post Driver Recommendations #4  
For one, you can hang the hydralic driver anywhere on the tractor ex. loader. The pto is locked in on the tph. I like the pto driver because you can leave the engine at idle and it will run plenty fast to drive any size post. I like it quite. /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif
 
   / Hydraulic Post Driver Recommendations #5  
Steve, I own a Worksaver HPD-20 SWO (offset hydraulic) that I run with my JD4700 CUT. I've driven approximately 1,500 posts with it in mostly sandy soil and it's performed pretty well. Many posts have been up to 8" diameter. My tractor's hydraulic flow is fine for the unit. The offset type has a balast box that you fill so the total weight is about 1800 lbs. This is as much as I'd want to lift with my 3PH. The HPD-16 SHC requires a tractor with a hydraulic system capable of 3-4 gpm at 1500 psi and no less than 35 hp. The unit weighs 723 lbs. You don't state if your NH-TDC-40 has a hydrostatic transmission but even if it does you should be OK (for hp). When the ram comes down the fluid has to be dumped immediately back into your tractor's hydraulic reservoir so the plumbing of the dump line is critical. I always have a loader on my tractor to counterbalance the weight and sometimes will the bucket to help depending upon terrain. For 400 posts, I would reconsider a PHD since this is considerably less expensive. The drivers, even with pointed posts, tend to have the posts wander if the ground is not uniform (rocks, roots, etc). Some of this can be corrected with the hydraulics. For normal fencing they are fine but for exact fencing (i.e. at the entrance of my farm) I used a PHD and string lines to accurately set my fences. I also used the PHD where the fences went through the woods due to many roots. Worksaver does stand behind their products. The master ram cylinder failed after a few hundred posts and they immediately sent a new one under warrenty. I was down for only a couple of days. The drive springs do break. One of mine broke around 1,000 posts so I replaced both. Kencove carries replacements. I've also bent two CAT 1 pins that attach the unit to my 3PH amazingly. I've set up to 120 posts in a day with a helper. Make certain your post tops are square and solid. Best of luck.
 
   / Hydraulic Post Driver Recommendations #6  
I've got the worksaver 20 and it works very well. I have had absolutely no problems with it and we've probably put in well over 2500 posts with it. My tractor is the 4600 and it handles it just fine. I don't think you'd have a problem with the tc40 but I don't know what your hydraulic capabilities are. Call worksaver and they will tell you. They were very helpful when I was getting mine. I was going to get the 16 as well but after talking to them they told me the 20 would be fine for my tractor.
 
   / Hydraulic Post Driver Recommendations #7  
The TC 35 thru 45 have about the same GPM flow
that the Deeres have.
 
   / Hydraulic Post Driver Recommendations
  • Thread Starter
#8  
I have 400 posts to put in this year, and probably as many the following year. I currently have a PHD (not a cheap one either) and I'm not terribly impressed with it. This impression is probably from the last section of fence I put up that apparently followed a buried stone wall half way around (about 25 posts). Those 25 posts represented one of the most frustrating weekends in my life. I also noticed that quite small rocks can hang it up if you hit them dead in the middle. But to be fair, I’d say the PHD did a fair job on 9 out of 10 holes if there was not a stone wall buried there. I also found backfilling and tamping to be a fair amount of work.

If I could put 100 posts in a day with the driver I’d be happy. That is many times my rate with the PHD and no time on the tamping bar. I’m putting up high tension PVC rail (with wires in the rail) so my posts will be 12’ apart. If I could keep my post within a couple inches of the line that would be fine. Does that seem reasonable? I have no roots but some fieldstone that comes into play about 15% of the time from my experience with the PHD. With the 12’ spacing and continuous belt I also have plenty of play back and forth along the line to reposition posts. Plus maybe the tension of the rail would help pull things into line when I crank it up.
 
   / Hydraulic Post Driver Recommendations
  • Thread Starter
#9  
Richard, can you give me some idea of how many posts a day you can do with your driver? How plumb are the posts and how well can you hold the line?
 
   / Hydraulic Post Driver Recommendations #10  
If all goes well and the soil is good I can do a post every five minutes with someone running the tractor.
 
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

Genie GS-4047 (A45046)
Genie GS-4047 (A45046)
PETERBILT FUEL TANK (A45046)
PETERBILT FUEL...
2018 LeeBoy 8520 Asphalt Paver  Kubota Diesel, Electric Legend Screed (A44789)
2018 LeeBoy 8520...
2023 New Holland T8.410 PowerShift  Low Hours, GPS Ready, Fully Loaded! (A44789)
2023 New Holland...
GENIE GS1930 (A45046)
GENIE GS1930 (A45046)
2016 Ford F-150 Pickup Truck (A44572)
2016 Ford F-150...
 
Top