Flail Mower FLAIL VS. ROTARY (FINISH) MOWER - PROS & CONS

   / FLAIL VS. ROTARY (FINISH) MOWER - PROS & CONS #1  

coastalguy

Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2006
Messages
40
Is there anyone who can explain the pros and cons of a flail mower to a finish rotary mower as well as the background of how the flail mower came about. I am looking in the 72"-84" range, normal grass, large acreage. I am guessing a flail mower doesn't clump the grass clippings as much. How about durability and operating and maintenance cost. Thanks in advance.

Coastalguy (with high grass)
 
   / FLAIL VS. ROTARY (FINISH) MOWER - PROS & CONS #2  
I wish I could tell you the pro's & con's about both mowers...but I can't. When I was purchasing my John Deere tractor, the dealer introduced me to one of his customers that had a "Trimax" flail mower behind his 3520 and he said it's the best thing he ever used for mowing. He said he can mow down entire hay fields (tall) and it looks just beautiful.

Now if you go to price flail mowers, they are quite a bit more costly than RFM's.
For my own puropses, I really want the flail mower, however, I've not made the decision just yet. We've got perhaps another month or so of growing season here in NY so I have time to think about spending that kind of money.

Good luck whatever mower you get.
Jon
 
   / FLAIL VS. ROTARY (FINISH) MOWER - PROS & CONS #3  
Caroni makes decent medium duty flail mowers that are quite cost competitive with RFMs. A 75" flail from AgriSupply can be had for just under $1600 plus shipping. They also have a 59" version for a couple hundred less.
http://www.agrisupplyco.com/page39
 
   / FLAIL VS. ROTARY (FINISH) MOWER - PROS & CONS #4  
Thanks for the info....the Trimax lists for around $4500 and that's a lot of $$ for a mower.

Jon
 
   / FLAIL VS. ROTARY (FINISH) MOWER - PROS & CONS #5  
The Trimax must be a heavy duty flail. I am sure it is very heavily built and could take the punishment associated with roadside maintenance or professional Ag use. The Caroni is no lightweight but I think is intended for somewhat less demanding applications.
 
   / FLAIL VS. ROTARY (FINISH) MOWER - PROS & CONS #6  
The only flail mower I have used was for ag use and about 20 foot wide. This was a hitch mounted, 1000 pto driven unit. You are considering a 6' 3pt mounted version but the principles are the same. We would use them to cut the wheat stubble after harvest and some times to cut corn stalks etc. Can be used for grass but we never did. Except for the width of cut I never liked the thing. They are noiser than a rotary mower, need to be run at pto speed, where a rotary mower can be run at slower speed if desired. Hope you never hit a rock, metal, wood or even the ground because the racket it causes is so severe you would think something would break. When the knives hit something, they are thrown in every direction and essentially hit other knives, the metal center drum or anything else in the vicinty on the mower. No realistic way to ever sharpen all of those flail cutters. Don't plan on using it to cut brush, trees ect. In general, they also seem to be more prone to scalping the dirt on uneven ground.

The advantages of a flail mower I can think of is it's ability to be lighter in weight for the width of cut and they don't hang as far behind the tractor as a rotary mower. They would also be better for not clumping the grass as it is cut.
 
   / FLAIL VS. ROTARY (FINISH) MOWER - PROS & CONS #7  
I would like to hear how a flail mower would compare to a regular rotary brushhog when cutting waist high weeds and grass?
 
   / FLAIL VS. ROTARY (FINISH) MOWER - PROS & CONS #8  
Flail mowers can be configured with either knives or "hammers". With knives they compare to finish mowers and with hammers to rotary "bush hogs". Overall the seem to be in between the two rotary mower styles.

I don't think anyone would recommend trying to run over 2 to 3 inch saplings with a flail mower but otherwise they apparently work as well as the rotary mowers with regard to hitting unseen objects etc. When you do need to service the knives or hammers, the job is certainly more complex than flipping a bush hog over and going at it with an angle grinder for five minutes. Each of the 50-80 knives/hammers has to be unbolted, sharpened or replaced and rebolted. Sounds like a whole rainy afternoon project to me.
 
   / FLAIL VS. ROTARY (FINISH) MOWER - PROS & CONS #9  
I have heard they have a finer cut that a RFM or a MMM?
 
   / FLAIL VS. ROTARY (FINISH) MOWER - PROS & CONS #10  
Gavman said:
I would like to hear how a flail mower would compare to a regular rotary brushhog when cutting waist high weeds and grass?

A flail mower will give you a cleaner look cutting a field of tall grass as it will chop it into smaller pieces but will receive more damage from rocks and small tress , brush etc... As a rotary cutter leaves long cut grass laying in the field and a finish mower just bogs down.

A rotary cutter is more durable and less maintenence.

A finish mower will do a better job on a lawn in my opinion
their is a JD 6' flail mower next store that hasn't been used for a couple of years that could be had pretty cheap.
he bought a RFM a couple of summers ago
 
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

Year: 2016 Make: Ford Model: Explorer Vehicle Type: Multipurpose Vehicle (MPV) Mileage: 112,123 (A44572)
Year: 2016 Make...
2015 FORD F-250 (INOPERABLE) (A45333)
2015 FORD F-250...
Deere 50G (A44501)
Deere 50G (A44501)
Wacker Neuson WP1550 Vibratory Plate Compactor (A42745)
Wacker Neuson...
2012 PETERBILT 367 FLATTOP SLEEPER (A45333)
2012 PETERBILT 367...
7’X20’ METAL FARM DRIVEWAY GATE (A45046)
7’X20’ METAL FARM...
 
Top