Cross Bows and Compound Bows

   / Cross Bows and Compound Bows #1  

thcri

Elite Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2003
Messages
4,653
Location
Minnesota SE
Tractor
New Holland TC29D, 2001
I have been thinking about getting a Bow to hunt deer with. I originally wanted a cross bow but was told I could not hunt deer with it in Minnesota. Now I am told that you can get a permit for a cross bow. But does anyone have any suggestions for the two styles of bows and recomendations.

Actually as many deer that come in my back yard at night I am sure I could get one pretty easy but still would rather hunt up north.


murph
 
   / Cross Bows and Compound Bows #2  
Don't know about Minn., but in Tx I believe you can get a permit for a crossbow only if you can show proof of a physical disability that prevents you from being able to shoot a regular bow.
Compound bows are amazingly easy to become proficient shooting. They are very accurate out to 35-40 yards with peep sights similar to shooting a rifle. I limit myself to no more than 30 yards and try to keep it less. The let off lets you shoot a 65-70 pound bow but hold less than half that. Go to a good archery shop with an indoor shooting range and get professional help.
 
   / Cross Bows and Compound Bows #3  
LA has same disabled law. A single cam compound is a good choice as they don't have 2 cams to get out of time.I got a nice 6pt first year I bought mine (after a summers worth of practice). I advise you to go to a bow shop and get fitted for your bow and don't get silly with the speed.
 
   / Cross Bows and Compound Bows #4  
Depending on the state you are in, there are different laws. In Pa they recently enacted a season where you can hunt antlerless deer with a crossbow. A friend of mine purchased a crossbow especially for this reason. All that I can tell you is that is maybe his crossbow is faster than my compound, I am more accurate with the compound than he is with the crossbow.
It all comes down to practice, If you practice enough with a compound bow, I think that you have just a good of a chance of bagging your quarry than those who use a crossbow.
 
   / Cross Bows and Compound Bows #5  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( Don't know about Minn., but in Tx I believe you can get a permit for a crossbow only if you can show proof of a physical disability that prevents you from being able to shoot a regular bow.)</font>

Mississippi is the same. I agree with going to bow shop and getting equiped. I really enjoyed just shooting my bow, even when I wasn't hunting. Sold mine about 20 years ago, but I have been seriously thinking about getting another one.
 
   / Cross Bows and Compound Bows
  • Thread Starter
#6  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( Don't know about Minn., but in Tx I believe you can get a permit for a crossbow only if you can show proof of a physical disability that prevents you from being able to shoot a regular bow.
)</font>


I guess that is what I am banking on. I did tear a rotator cuff three years ago and since I have done that I can not stretch my left arm very far. So there would be a chance that I could get one.

So if anyone has any ideas on brand or type I sure would appreciat it.

murph
murph
 
   / Cross Bows and Compound Bows #7  
In Mississippi you are required to provide documentation of your disability from two different doctors before they will allow you to hunt with a crossbow. So you might want to start the process now and get all your permits early. Sorry for this long post, but I have just got to tell this story regarding permits, and crossbows.

My older brother lived to deer hunt. He was struck with two highly malignant brain tumors August of 03. By deer season, he was so debilitated he had to be in a wheelchair, but he still had use of his right arm. He asked us to take him deer hunting just one more time before he died. His buddys at work had welded him up a rest on his wheelchair for his crossbow and we practiced off his patio in his back yard.

We had the two letters from the doctors, but time was really critical, so I started calling every State Game agency I could think of to expedite the process. I faxed and called all my congressmen and reps hoping they might have some pull to hurry it along. I hit a brick wall with a beauricratic woman at the Ms Game and Fish Commision. She had to have the original letters from the doctors, a fax was not sufficient. We'd have to go through the normal process like everyone else. After several calls begging and pleading with the woman to no avail, I called one of the regional game wardens and spoke to him about Don. He told me to "take him hunting and don't worry about it". I had already planned on doing it anyway, but it was good to at least have somebody's blessing if we were caught.

We built him a blind with some rope and camo fabric around some trees, and sat out there all day. We didn't see any sign of a deer all day, and he never took a shot. But just being in the woods in his camo, with that crossbow was the thrill of his last month alive.

Two weeks after his "hunt", by which time he was so debilitated he could no longer sit up in his chair, I get a call on my cellphone. It's the women telling me they had recieved his letters and she was working to get him his permit. I told her to throw it all in the trash, as we had spoken to "one of the guys in our region" and he had told us to "take him hunting" and we had done just that about two weeks ago. I told her somewhat sarcastically I "appreciated" her help and hung up. Would you believe that not 5 minutes later my phone rang , and it was her again. I guess she thought I was a total idiot, because she asked "Would you mind giving me that officers name who told you to take him, JUST for our records." I couldn't believe that she would attempt to try and discipline that warden for makingg such a kind and humane allowance for another human being. I let her have it with both barrells! Just before I hung up on her, I told her I'd be happy to provide her with his name, if "she'd provide me with letters from two doctors certifying she had a heart, as it was obvious to me she was one heartless B***H!" /forums/images/graemlins/mad.gif

I couldn't believe I had said what I did to her, but I just couldn't help myself. I can tell you quite truthfully however, that I felt reallllll good after having said it!

Mostly I couldn't believe myself, for even giving a minutes thought to the possiblity that I couldn't have taken him hunting unless we got that permit. I'd gladly pay any fines and penalties if I could do that for him again!

Come to think of it, his birthday was this past Wednesday. Thanks for allowing me this small "tribute".

I hope you have better luck than we did.
 
   / Cross Bows and Compound Bows
  • Thread Starter
#8  
Ken,

Your story is touching. I am sorry to hear about your brother.

What you did was totally in the right. Unfortunately our government agencies have it all turned around. They are suppose to be working for us, not us working for them. Their rules are great but with all rules there is a time when they should be bent. This is what you did and I will back you up 110%. And the lady, no doubt she has no heart and am glad I don't know her.

Thanks for your tribute.


murph
 
   / Cross Bows and Compound Bows #9  
murph - When it comes to brand of bows, that is kind of like our discussions of brand of tractor. There are numerous name brands now and a lot of lesser known brands. There are all sorts of different gimmicks each of which claim to be the best. I would suggest going to a good archery shop and talk to someone knowledgeable. More than one shop if there are several in your area to get different view points. You can get in for around $200 or so or you can go up to $1000 or more. Then you start adding on the accessories. Sights, quivers, arrows-aluminum or carbon, arrow heads, etc. That will add more than a few more dollars.
 
   / Cross Bows and Compound Bows #10  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( So if anyone has any ideas on brand or type I sure would appreciat it. )</font>

Barnett has been around a long time. I think all they do is crossbows. I've heard of Horton and Bear (Fred) also, but couldn't comment to quality.

Best of luck.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2015 Ford Focus SE Sedan (A50324)
2015 Ford Focus SE...
2016 FORD F-350 XL SUPER DUTY CREW CAB FLATBED (A51243)
2016 FORD F-350 XL...
2020 Ford F-150 Crew Cab Pickup Truck (A50323)
2020 Ford F-150...
2018 JLG 3246ES 32ft Electric Scissor Lift (A50322)
2018 JLG 3246ES...
2018 Komatsu WA500-8 Articulated Wheel Loader (A50322)
2018 Komatsu...
2011 Chevrolet Traverse SUV (A50324)
2011 Chevrolet...
 
Top