Finally broke something

/ Finally broke something
  • Thread Starter
#22  
/ Finally broke something #23  
Try it now.
 
/ Finally broke something #24  
Most folks on TBN browse by "new posts" and don't limit themselves to just the brands of tractors they own. And most folks here have decades of experience on many brands of tractors. It would be silly to think people should recuse themselves from participating in threads on TBN just because of the brand. Similarly, folks who are new to the forum and/or tractors should be more open to advice from the experienced folks here. I can understand the skepticism, as we have seen many many threads from people who broke their tractor doing something stupid, and I am sure many people in the thread broke their tractor doing something stupid. I don't think that's the case here -- sounds like the OP was just doing routine work -- but I bet most people just jumped to a certain conclusion based on past experience.

We've seen failures from all the brands and in many cases it's obvious it was a material/manufacturing defect. No brand is immune to it. Pictures can be really helpful in diagnosing that.

absolutely agree with that for the most part. I've done it myself, something stupid that is. Tomorrow is a new day full of new opportunities too! :laughing:

I just found it somewhat curious that the 'naysayers' were different brand owners. Not knocking the orange or green, as I have in times past either owned or operated both for extended periods. Maybe it's just me, but I actually DON'T go to the other brands threads. I'm sure there are decades of experience there to add to my decades of experience. Just doesn't interest me to go peruse the orange and green threads. Not ALL those folks, but some are clearly tractor snobs who look down at each other based on size (in their own brands) or color if it happens to be a different one. Now throw in a cheaper one too....and well....
 
/ Finally broke something #25  
I'm just sitting at my breakfast table looking at my smart phone and it alerted me that this thread was trending. I dont even know what an LS brand is. I've got service manuals for MF and mahindra. Both are red. My green tractor is just over 1 year old and is not perfect and the deer dudes weren't much help when our baler broke. We had to diagnose and ID the right part after buying the wrong one. The guy that works on zero turns at JD is top notch. The rest just do the best they can. I imagine there's a lot of collaboration at the shop before they get it fixed.
 
/ Finally broke something #26  
I just found it somewhat curious that the 'naysayers' were different brand owners. Not knocking the orange or green, as I have in times past either owned or operated both for extended periods...

What's funny is when the orange guys attack each other. I read most threads here more or less out of boredom. Some are more general even though they're in a brand thread.
 
/ Finally broke something #28  
absolutely agree with that for the most part. I've done it myself, something stupid that is. Tomorrow is a new day full of new opportunities too! :laughing:

I just found it somewhat curious that the 'naysayers' were different brand owners. Not knocking the orange or green, as I have in times past either owned or operated both for extended periods. Maybe it's just me, but I actually DON'T go to the other brands threads. I'm sure there are decades of experience there to add to my decades of experience. Just doesn't interest me to go peruse the orange and green threads. Not ALL those folks, but some are clearly tractor snobs who look down at each other based on size (in their own brands) or color if it happens to be a different one. Now throw in a cheaper one too....and well....

We have Kubotas, but I have driven machines made by Kubota, Deere, Cat, LS, Kioti, Case, Massey, NH, Bolens, Cub Cadet, Huskavarna and eXmark. They are all similar, they all break eventually and the guys at the dealer are all recruited from the same pool of mechanics.
The warranties are also all similar, the competence of the dealer will depend on their mechanics, what is covered (vs being classed as "abuse") will depend on how much pull the dealer has with their area rep, how much they want to push for you, how you broke it and if your story matches the way that it looks like it broke.

The LS dealer that we bought a tractor from at work was pretty good on the mechanical side (other than selling us a tractor that was more than 1000# overweight on the front axle with the blade that they mounted on the loader, it should have come with a weight box on the back), but they were lost on the computer side for complicated stuff.


Aaron Z
 
/ Finally broke something #29  
Picture: Shared album - Ty Mixon - Google Photos

So . . . looks like one of us did hit something. Just after that silver scrap there's a noticeable bend.

I'll email my dealership and see what they say. :)

I wouldn't be surprised if your Dealer didn't say something like, 'sucks to be you' and wishes you luck. Maybe you can work outside the Dealer for a solution that does't cost you an arm and a leg and will allow you to get your Tractor up and running in hours rather than days or weeks.

1. I don't want to be in the same Zip Code when your Wife sees that bar on her tile floor.

2. I don't see why you can't find a track bar, drag link, steering bar or whatever they want to call it from a supplier along with the appropriate sleeves and thread your tie rod ends into it.

I would think a suspension shop in the area should be able to hook you up. Hopefully.

I'm just wondering, just asking. I don't know from applebutter but keep us informed.

Enquiring minds.........................
 
/ Finally broke something
  • Thread Starter
#30  
@Username Taken

1. No wife, cheap roll out linoleum in my office.

2. Just emailed the dealer with the pic, and waiting to see what they say. As they dropped the ball on properly installing my 3rd function, and I didn't try to get one over on them, I'm hoping they will go above what is minimally required.
 
/ Finally broke something #31  
Most folks on TBN browse by "new posts" and don't limit themselves to just the brands of tractors they own. And most folks here have decades of experience on many brands of tractors. It would be silly to think people should recuse themselves from participating in threads on TBN just because of the brand. Similarly, folks who are new to the forum and/or tractors should be more open to advice from the experienced folks here. I can understand the skepticism, as we have seen many many threads from people who broke their tractor doing something stupid, and I am sure many people in the thread broke their tractor doing something stupid. I don't think that's the case here -- sounds like the OP was just doing routine work -- but I bet most people just jumped to a certain conclusion based on past experience.

We've seen failures from all the brands and in many cases it's obvious it was a material/manufacturing defect. No brand is immune to it. Pictures can be really helpful in diagnosing that.

Yes this !!!
 
/ Finally broke something #32  
The tie-rod is a common part, and should be too expensive. You were able to disassemble it already so reassembling it with the new one is doable. Since you know you caused the failure, I would be very thankful if the dealer paid for the part, and not upset if they didn't. You're lucky you didn't break the cast portion when you ran it into something. That would be more expensive to repair.
 
/ Finally broke something
  • Thread Starter
#33  
The tie-rod is a common part, and should be too expensive. You were able to disassemble it already so reassembling it with the new one is doable. Since you know you caused the failure, I would be very thankful if the dealer paid for the part, and not upset if they didn't. You're lucky you didn't break the cast portion when you ran it into something. That would be more expensive to repair.

Yep, that's my mind set too. I won't ***** if they don't warranty it, and I'll say great things about them if they do. :)
 
/ Finally broke something #34  
Yep, that's my mind set too. I won't ***** if they don't warranty it, and I'll say great things about them if they do. :)
I think my dealer would warenty it but then i do have a great dealer, but if not i would just straighten it out the best i could replace whats needed and reinstall and readjust the tow in.
Good Luck my Louisiana friend!
I think over the years i had most of the tractor brands and liked all of them all including a Chinese tractor i now have had since 05 or 06. I do love tractors.
 
/ Finally broke something
  • Thread Starter
#35  
Walter,

That bit at the end that's broken off is where the threads are. I can't fix that, and I'm not sure it's be easily fixable any way.

And as the tractor is under warranty, might as well replace it with an LS part to keep the warranty up.
 
/ Finally broke something #36  
Good luck with your dealer. They have latitude in what they can cover under warranty. They are in business to make money and also in business to keep happy customers. It's not easy. Since that arm is bent they may tell you operator error and not warrantied. They may tell you operator error but we will still warranty it. Or they may just charge you cost for the part and then make it up on the install. Good luck and keep us updated.

I'm 59 years old and my dad sold tractors for a living. I've lived on the farm most of my life and run a lot of different equipment and a lot of different manufacturers. They all have their issues.
 
/ Finally broke something
  • Thread Starter
#38  
They warrantied it. Put it back on in about 10 mins w/ my brothers help. Tractor is now doing well, but it's too muddy to do the work we need done.
 
/ Finally broke something #39  
I'm glad. May not be a bull doze but random limbs shouldn't easily get to the weaker parts.
 
/ Finally broke something #40  
Same thing with Avenger's thread. He admitted to them he hit/broke a part, but they replaced it under warranty. Some things just shouldn't break, even if you do something wrong by accident.
 

Marketplace Items

2019 WABASH DVLSHPC 53FT DRY VAN TRAILER (A59905)
2019 WABASH...
2023 Kubota BX1880V-1 Sub - Compact Utility Tractor with 54-Inch Mower Deck (A61306)
2023 Kubota...
Morgan 26ft Box Truck Body (A59230)
Morgan 26ft Box...
1998 Mazda B2500 (A57149)
1998 Mazda B2500...
2013 Jeep Wrangler 4x4 SUV (A59231)
2013 Jeep Wrangler...
2018 PINSA 130BBL VACUUM TRAILER (A58214)
2018 PINSA 130BBL...
 
Top